Friday, August 9, 2013

Conservative Thinking


When I find things to read that stick with me, things I want to have access to later to reread or get quotes, I often save a copy in my personal files. Lately a number of those “keepers” happened to come from a source that I’m only just becoming familiar with. The site is TheImaginativeConservative.org. I referred to one of their pieces in Wednesday’s blog.
So I started looking more at this source, TIC for short. Several of the first contributors listed are affiliated with Hillsdale College, which does some heroic work in sharing the concepts and philosophies that led to our Constitution. But other names are from various other places, though more college professors than other walks of life. I can’t say I agree with everything I’ve read from their site, but I think there’s definitely enough good there to pay attention. Sometimes the topics refer back and forth between the writings of various philosophers, and I don’t qualify as fully well-read with all those names. But sometimes these are clues to what I should go read. There have been a couple of mentions that the writers are all Christian, so I think that may be part of their worldview as well. At one point I thought they might be libertarian and secularist; but the more I read, the more I find that to be simply an error on my part.
Russell Kirk
photo from Wikipedia
TIC became on online newsletter in 2010, started by Winston Elliott III, who became president of the Free Enterprise Institute in 1992. He was greatly influenced by the conservative writings of Russell Kirk. The site states the mission this way:

Dr. [Russell] Kirk’s work informs the mission of The Imaginative Conservative, which is to be a forum for those who seek the True, the Good and the Beautiful. We address culture, liberal learning, politics, political economy, literature, the arts and the American Republic in the tradition of Russell Kirk, T.S. Eliot, Edmund Burke, Irving Babbitt, Paul Elmer More, Wilhelm Roepke, Robert Nisbet, M.E. Bradford, Christopher Dawson and other leaders of Imaginative Conservatism.
The headings of categories on their site include books (reviews of books), conservatism, Russell Kirk, politics, culture, American Republic, liberal learning (in the sense of freedom and open-mindedness, or classical liberal thought, not the redefined word used the past century), economics, and bookstore. There categories fit relatively well with mine: political sphere, economic sphere, and culture/civilization sphere. Some things cross over enough (like education, for example) that they fit partially under all, which you would expect when the three spheres interrelate and spatially overlie each other.
A number of pieces written by Russell Kirk are included on the site.
The Essence of Conservatism, by Russell Kirk.   Just last post I was searching for ways to define and thereby differentiate conservatism and libertarianism. This definition of conservatism is a good addition to the conversation:
A conservative is not, by definition, a selfish or a stupid person; instead, he is a person who believes there is something in our life worth saving. Conservatism, indeed, is a word with an old and honorable meaning—but a meaning almost forgotten by Americans until recent years. Abraham Lincoln wished to be known as a conservative. “What is conservatism?” he said. “Is it not preference for the old and tried, over the new and untried?” It is that; and it is also a body of ethical and social beliefs. The word “liberalism,” however, has been in favor among us for two or three decades. Even nowadays, though there are a good many conservatives in both national and state politics, in neither major party do many leading politicians describe themselves as “conservatives.” Paradoxically, the people of the United States became the chief conservative nation of the world at the very time when they had ceased to call themselves conservatives at home.
Ten Conservative Principles, by Russell Kirk   This one also adds body to the definition. If you're wondering whether you align with conservatism, his ten principles might help with your introspection.
There are some other TIC pieces, by other writers, I’d like to recommend for your summer reading pleasure. But, to give myself room to comment, I think I’ll save those until the next post.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Libertarians on the Sphere

I’ve noticed something of a name-calling rift recently between people who are really pretty close to agreement: general conservatives and libertarians. It seems more worthwhile to work on repair there than on the huge chasm between conservatives and tyrannists (liberals/progressives/statists).

Let’s start with definitions, because that might provide some stitches to the wound right there.
·        Conservatives believe in conserving and protecting the natural God-given rights, and believe the US Constitution, as written and understood at the time of the founding, is well-suited to provide those protections.
·        Conservatives believe the person best suited to deciding how wealth should be spent is the person who earned it. While there will be inevitable inequities and poor, free-choice charity is better than statist coercion to see to people’s needs. (I think this is also a pretty good statement of libertarian belief.)
·        Conservatives believe in supporting the values and institutions that have led to civilization in the past, and are necessary for civilization: a religious people (because God granted the rights we enjoy), who live basic rules of decency, such as the Ten Commandments, in order to live in harmony with others; and support of strong traditional families (married mother and father raising their own children) so that the necessary values of civilization will be passed from one generation to the next. 

·        Libertarians believe that all decisions about how a life should be lived should be decided by the individual, as long as the person’s behavior doesn’t interfere with or harm others.
I should be able to come up with more that this single principle for libertarianism, but, as often happens, it’s difficult from the outside. I am a conservative. While I enjoy conversations with libertarians and find a great deal of common ground, I don’t find their single principle philosophy sufficient.
A couple of days ago I read a long piece (linked at The Imaginative Conservative, by Nathan Schlueter, associate professor of philosophy at Hillsdale College) listing several basic libertarian statements, and then carefully debunking them from the conservative position. It is worth reading. Here are a few of the statements it deals with:
·        Only individuals exist; therefore there is no such thing as a “common good.”
·        The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.
·        Virtue cannot be coerced; therefore government should not legislate morality.
·        The only alternative to libertarianism is totalitarianism.
I like the response to the question of the purpose of law, because all law identifies what society views as appropriate or not:
The law, both by prohibition and by silence, is a powerful signal of acceptable behavior, and thus a powerful influence on character. When the behavior in question involves moral norms that are consequential for the rest of society, it is a proper object of law.
You can’t have civilization, which requires strongly supporting the family, if you have no way of disapproving of sex for sale, for example. You can’t protect personal freedom if you have no way of disapproving of the sale of mind-altering addictive drugs, which result in loss of personal choice and lead to harm of the individual and often to a fair amount of collateral damage.
Back in May 2011 I wrote about why I’m not quite a libertarian. And I described it in relation to the Spherical Model. Libertarians often coincide with conservatives, because it is so often the case that the appropriate level of interest is the most local: individual and family. (Libertarians might or might not include family as qualifying in their philosophy.) So often the problems with government and society are caused by usurpation by an entity too far removed from the most local interest.
But it’s the assumption that the dichotomy is between libertarianism and totalitarianism that causes problems. It shows that libertarians, even when their behavior and outcome put them in the freedom zone, get there sort of accidentally. Like tyrannists, they can only visualize the southern hemisphere. They don’t even know that there’s a freedom zone up there in the northern hemisphere.
I haven’t shown this visually on the sphere before, so I’m giving that a try today with my whiteboard (where is a computer graphic designer when you need one?) The drawing is the basic Spherical Model. Southward is toward tyranny, controlled economy, and savagery; northward is toward freedom, free enterprise, and civilization. North is good; south is bad. But longitude depends on the appropriate level of interest. The range is from individual/family (most local) on the most westward side of the globe, moving (either left or right) to the other side of the sphere with world interests as the far eastward extreme (not visible on this diagram, because we can only see a hemisphere at a time). The range spreads out from individual/family, to community, to county or area, to state or province, to nation, to continent or region, to world.
In principle, according to the Spherical Model, the most local interest that can handle an issue should handle it. Since this often means individual and family, there’s a natural agreement with libertarians. Libertarians, philosophically (but not practically, if you actually talk it out) don’t believe in the value of any affiliation beyond the individual. So they don’t really value community, state, or national governments—even though they do concede that there needs to be law to protect people from those who would do them harm.
In the diagram, there’s a narrow range (in red) at or around the individual longitude line, going all the way from the north pole to the south. In the northern hemisphere, conservatives spend a lot of time in that same zone, pulling always more local, since there has been so much usurpation by less local entities. But for conservatives, the goal is to remain upward in the freedom/free-enterprise/civilization zone—whether or not that requires only family control, or whether the state or nation is the most appropriate placement (for border security, for example). While it’s hard to come up with interests beyond the purview of the nation, and even more unlikely to see the need for an international entity with power beyond suggestion, conservatives do embrace the entire freedom zone.
Libertarians, meanwhile, limit their vision to that long, narrow strip of the sphere, and only enjoy true freedom, prosperity, and civilization when they happen to coincide with conservatives on specific issues—often the economic issues. But it tends to be on the issues of civilization where the rift appears. They may be right that people can’t be coerced to be virtuous, but the law does serve the purpose of providing expectations, so even the naturally unvirtuous have an incentive to behave virtuously. Then the virtuous-by-choice are not forced to live in—and accept as normal—an uncivilized society.
The debate is valuable. Many conservatives don’t well articulate the principles of conservatism either, or even recognize the underlying philosophy. It strengthens us all to be able to talk through our views, and find the areas of agreement—and maybe persuade libertarian individuals to add conservative principles to their too-limited worldview. With a lot of well-meaning, thinking people who value freedom, we can gain strength together.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Floating vs. Flailing

In the summer I swim at the neighborhood pool for exercise. This is Houston; you’re going to be drenched whatever exercise you do, so it might as well be in a pool, where it’s at least cooler. I am not a strong swimmer; I never really got down the breathing rhythm. I need to breathe whenever I’m out of air, without needing to turn my head and wait for pouring water to get out of the way before I gasp. So, I mostly do a slow slow breaststroke with head up out of the water, or sidestroke (I know no one else does that, but I learned it back in the day as a precursor to learning lifesaving, which I fortunately haven’t had to use, because I need a lot more training for that). After I do a certain number of laps, I go into the deep end and tread water for a while. This is aerobic exercise for me, even if it’s never going to earn me any kind of award. I enjoy the sort of zen-like, meditative quality of it, now that I’m going to the pool without wild children.

I do have a special swimming talent—I can float. I mean, all I need to do is lie back and maybe occasionally move a foot or hand. It’s almost embarrassing how easy it is to float—I don’t even need an inflatable anything. I don’t actually do it very much, since I’m swimming in public.
I used to believe this was just a matter of learning well from the technique-minded Swedish lady who taught us kids swimming every summer for probably a decade when I was a kid. “You are such a beautiful swimmer,” she kept saying in her lovely accent, even though I spent the first summer clinging to the side with one hand and holding my nose with the other. And it took several years to build up courage to dive (I practiced in a basement spare bedroom, jumping from a chest of drawers onto the bed—don’t tell my mom.) My son Political Sphere managed these skills easily at age two with water wings, and didn’t need the flotation devices much beyond that. I had way too much fear in my way.
But my breaststroke became smooth, and actually was kind of beautiful in a very non-competitive kind of way. And I could float, even as a skinny child. At my age now, it looks like I have the advantage of a buoyant type. But that doesn’t explain why Mr. Spherical Model has never been able to float, either as a skinny kid, or as a more substantial very big man. In fact, no one in the family can just lie back and float effortlessly like I do. It still could be partly technique (I think they just allow too much bending in the middle, which leads to sinking). But without knowing the reasons, it seems like I have something of a special power.
At church Sunday a man in our congregation was talking about faith. He is a faithful person, has been all his life. But for him it is a matter of hard swimming to stay afloat, while for his wife it seems like effortless floating. When he feels that panicky feeling like he could be sinking, he talks with her, sees the ease of her powerful, calm faith, and is buoyed up.
I was reminded of a line from The Other Side of Heaven. It’s a memoir of John H. Groberg as a Mormon missionary to Tonga in the1950s. (It was made into a rather sweet little movie some years ago, with Christopher Gorham as Elder Groberg, and Anne Hathaway as the girl writing to him from back home.) In the opening chapter he tells of being shipwrecked between islands, which required some hours of swimming to shore. He says, “I have heard it said that sometimes the lord calms the storm, and sometimes He lets the storm rage and calms His child.”
Movie cover from here
My floating ability would help me survive longer on an open sea than without it, but there’s also a great benefit from strong, effective strokes in the right direction. The difficulty, then, is knowing the right direction.
So, I’m thinking of this metaphorically, the ability to float rather than flail, and also the ability to swim hard effective strokes rather than flail, and even flailing enough to keep a head up long enough for relief to come. Life presents so many ways these ideas could be applied. Let me use just one today, related to these Spherical Model ideas.
I think of my ability to float as similar to understanding with calmness what the principles are that lead to thriving—in civilization, economic prosperity, and political freedom. For some reason I can make the connections and see the overall vision and connections. Instead of near drowning in the raging ocean of life in this world, I’m floating in the “calm lagoon” on the shores of the “idyllic island” of human happiness people are looking for. It’s a matter of doing the right things in the right place.
There are others who, in their strength, swim strongly from one point to another, looking for the idyllic island shore. They use a lot of energy ending up on jutting rocks where there’s no safety or permanent respite from the raging sea. I have known some of these swimmers. They’re often young, often intellectual. But they won’t abide some simple direction like, “Straighten and arch your back, and otherwise relax and let the waves carry you to shore.” Or, in this case, “Grant government only limited powers to protect God-given rights; expect to solve economic problems with effective work combined with philanthropy; and live the Ten Commandments, and pass along morality through the family.” They reply, “Too simple. That can't be it. I’ll just keep swimming and looking.” At every jutting rock they stop and yell out, “I’ve found it; you should come here,” and then they dive back in and search some more.
Others, without either the calmness to live the “floating” principles or the strength to direct themselves through trial and error, simply flail and hope for a rescuer before they go under. I've known those as well.
For those of us who are enjoying the cool calm water of the “lagoon,” and the warm sand of the “idyllic island” shore, the challenge is to get the word out to those who are madly swimming through the surf in the wrong direction, or who are flailing around directionless. We need to put up more guiding lights upon the shore.

Friday, August 2, 2013

Kleptomania Analogy

In Wednesday’s post we were talking about analogies that show the absurdity of claiming behavioral urges make a person “be” something, which leads to the assumption that the behavior should be accepted, even honored, so as not to offend the person. In passing I mentioned a piece I’d written some years ago, and I’m sharing that today. 

I wrote this in 2008, and shared it with people who were working on the Prop 8 campaign in California. But to my knowledge it was used as background, not published, so I hadn’t included it in my recent Defense of Marriage collection. The full piece begins with several paragraphs identifying the unique benefits of marriage to society: This covenant values exclusivity (so that inheritance rights are meaningful, and sexually transmitted diseases are not a threat), possibility of offspring, and permanence (so that offspring have a stable home in which to be raised). Despite Kennedy’s opinion in the Supreme Court ruling in Windsor a month ago that no one can have a rational reason for the traditional definition of marriage, these benefits are real, well documented and mounting in social science, and exemplified in some six millennia of human history.  

I have covered these reasons elsewhere in my writings, so for today I’ll mostly just include the analogy portion of the piece, meant to illustrate what happened 40 years ago to set in motion the propaganda that has been trying to control what the public “knows,” which doesn’t happen to be true.
_____________________________ 

Alternative Reality

Homosexuals are not prohibited from marrying a person of the opposite sex who is not a close relative, who is of legal age, and who is not already married to another person—the same criteria required of heterosexuals. 

But they can’t marry the person they would choose! Neither can heterosexuals who would choose someone too closely related, too young, or currently married, limitations that are intended to make marriage relationships most likely to be valuable to society rather than detrimental. So what homosexuals are saying, really, is that they want a change in the law to accommodate their particular desires, without showing that their relationship choices will be of value to society. 

If they were to get what they want, then society is deprived of a way to encourage permanent, faithful opposite-sex parents to maintain stable families in which to raise offspring—a way it has had for six thousand-plus years. And their reason for depriving society is just because they claim it’s unfair to them not to get their way. 

Their main argument presupposes that homosexuality is an innate quality, like race, inborn and immutable. But common sense tells us that behavior does not qualify as an inborn immutable quality; behavior is what we do, by choice (even if there doesn’t seem to be a lot of choice because the urge is strong, just as it is for a child rapist/murderer, which is, by the way, just another sexual orientation among a couple dozen). 

So how did we as a society come to believe that homosexuality was a trait, innate and unchangeable? By scientific study and discovery? Overwhelming evidence? Not exactly. 

To show you how it happened, it might help to look at an allegorical situation, a story: 

Once upon a time, in the early 1970s, there were certain members of the governing body of the American Psychiatric Association who had traits not common to the population at large. They had an alternative view of ownership, which led them, at times, to see the belongings of other people as their own. Previously among their colleagues there had been a term for this condition: kleptomania. It was considered a mental disorder that could be treated. There were studies about the condition, and new treatments being tried, to alter what was viewed as an unwanted, undesirable behavior problem. 

But these particular alternative-ownership perceivers didn’t think their problem should be treated. They liked perceiving other people’s belongings as their own. To them, it wasn’t harmful or undesirable. And they didn’t think it should be viewed as undesirable to their colleagues. Over several years, they combined together to build their political authority in the professional organization; also, they organized pressure groups from outside the organization to help them lobby. And they were able to proclaim that kleptomania was not a behavioral disorder. It was an inborn trait, a different ownership orientation, and was as valid as any other ownership orientation. It should not be treated. Studies should no longer be done in order to discover causes and cures.  

Instead, society should be persuaded to accept the differently ownership oriented. Anyone who refused to agree would be labeled kleptophobic. Presentations would be given in schools—first colleges, then high schools, and eventually elementary schools, to indoctrinate the public to accept this new view of kleptomania. Illustrated books would be written for school children: Mommy Found Yet Another Pair of Shoes, and You Might Be Differently Ownership Oriented; You Won’t Know until You Try. Laws were put before legislative bodies to declare it a crime to discriminate against someone just because they might be differently ownership oriented. Despite heavy lobbying against it from the greedy retail industry, many places did pass the legislation. Television began to put more and more differently ownership oriented persons in their programming, and began to portray them not as the butt of jokes, but as positive role models that simply suffered misunderstanding from a bigoted public. 

A few kleptomaniacs (pardon me, differently ownership oriented individuals) continued to seek treatment, although treatment was no longer sanctioned. They claimed the lifestyle made them suffer guilt, for taking things that didn’t belong to them. And it undermined trust, so that their relationships weren’t as intimate and lasting as they hoped for. And, despite the insistence that their behavioral urges were an innate trait, many were able to leave the lifestyle. Thousands, in fact. They were able to stop taking things that didn’t belong to them. Many were very nearly able to completely overcome the urge to take things. And these former kleptomaniacs held conferences to tell people there was hope for them, if they also wanted to change. But the supporters of the differently ownership oriented rallied against them, and often the six sign-holding protestors would be featured in news stories where the 2,000 conference goers’ views would not be considered newsworthy. 

[Forty] years of kleptomania acceptance indoctrination netted some results. It became popular for the elite to support the differently ownership oriented. It became shameful to say, in public, that you didn’t like it when differently ownership oriented people took your belongings. People publicly viewed kleptomania with acceptance, and many even encouraged the uncertainly oriented to give it a try.  

But the additional acceptance, for some reason, didn’t seem to benefit civilization.  

Traces of old paradigms remained. Still, people weren’t more likely to invite the differently ownership oriented to socialize with them in their homes. And there continued a serious prejudice against them in the retail workplace and among certain traditionalist religions which clung to the Ten Commandments as if they still mattered. Also, people tended to hold on more tightly than ever to their personal belongings when in public where they might unknowingly come in contact with the differently ownership oriented. People are, after all, naturally bigoted and hard to change. 

OK, so kleptomania didn’t get taken from the long (and almost inexhaustible) list of treatable behavioral problems. But in 1973 homosexuality did.[1] There were at that time some 600 ongoing studies into causes and treatments. There were thousands of people who had been successfully treated. But because of the political pressure from some few homosexual activists in the leadership of the American Psychological Association along with a few well-funded pressure groups, studies and treatments were axed.  

Those seeking treatment were turned away or told that “treatment” meant “accepting yourself as you are.”[2] Those who have found treatment despite its scarcity have a relatively high success rate, particularly when religion is a factor in the treatment (reference).  

But society is told this behavior problem is an innate immutable trait. Society has been lied to. 

Should society, based on the political pressure of a few behaviorally warped psychiatrists, throw out the institution of marriage in favor of honoring a behavior that does not benefit society and arguably harms the individual as well? No, it should not. 


[1] A thorough retelling of the sequence of events is covered in Destructive Trends in MentalHealth, by Rogers H. Wright and Nicholas A. Cummings; see the chapter on this subject by William T. O'Donohue and Christine E. Caselles.
Also, United Families International includes this information in their Family Issues Guide—Sexual Orientation, p. 9:
Myth:  Homosexual behavior should be considered normal as a result of the decision made by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) in 1973 which removed homosexuality from its list of “disorders.”
Reality:  The decision to remove homosexuality from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) was made after APA leaders and members had endured several years of intense political pressure and disruptive lobbying efforts by militant homosexual activist groups. (Ronald Bayer, “Homosexuality and American Psychiatry:  The Politics of Diagnosis,” Princeton University Press, 1987.)  Homosexual activist groups pressured APA committees to remove homosexuality from the APA’s approved list of disorders. In spite of the long documented history showing that therapists have helped homosexual clients reduce and change their homosexual tendencies, professionals who persist in viewing and treating homosexuality as a changeable condition are labeled unenlightened, prejudiced, homophobic, and unethical. There is currently a movement within the APA to normalize pedophilia that appears to be following the same path to legitimization as homosexuality. See Fast Facts and Commentary #1-66, 90-97.
 
[2] In addition, there is pressure against psychology students to even question the dogma. A good illustration is a seven-part piece in 2007 by Mike Adams, “Of Mice and Mormons,” about a family therapy master’s degree student who asked his program supervisor where to refer a client who was asking for help with unwanted same-sex attraction; for asking the question, the student was persecuted: Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, Part V, Part VI, Part VII.
 

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

To Be (Ser) or To Be (Estar)

The other day I got a call from my son Political Sphere, on his way home from work (a summer internship clerking with a county judge in a small county closer to Dallas than to Houston). He has an hour-plus, mostly rural, commute, so sometimes he sets the phone on hands-free and we chat. He is working on an upcoming guest post, maybe two-parts—a legal analysis of the Windsor case (recent Supreme Court ruling on DOMA). And so, slightly related to that as conversations go, we talked about the Pope’s comments in Brazil over the weekend.

The Pope did not announce any new policy or doctrine, but his candid style seems to get media thinking they’re hearing something new. He said that people with same-sex attraction who nevertheless seek to obey God’s law will be treated the same as anyone else seeking to obey God’s law. The quote that got the attention was, “If someone is gay and he searches for the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge?” It was in response to a question asked during a casual press conference regarding whether there is a “gay lobby” at the Vatican, which he declined to acknowledge.
He reiterated the longstanding policy that homosexuality is a sin, and that same-sex attraction cannot be acted upon. But he separates out “people who are gay” from “people who struggle same-sex attraction.”
I’m thinking the difference is clarified by a little Spanish grammar lesson, so I will insert that here. The verb “ser” means “to be,” permanently: he is tall; she is Argentinian. The verb “estar” means “to be” in a temporary state: he is hungry; she is thrilled—or “She is (está) white as a ghost from fear” rather than “She is (es) white, with ancestors from Finland.”
"To Be or Not To Be"--Shakespeare
photo from here
The Pope seems to have a pastoring, shepherding instinct to seek out those who are (están) dealing with any human frailty, including same-sex attraction. When dealing with a behavior that may or may not be engaged in, one doesn’t say those people are (son) homosexual—a way of being at all times regardless of behavior choices. So, while his tone seems to meet the approval of the press, he simply restated the Catholic position, while subtly pointing out that “lobbying” for homosexuality or anything else at the Vatican, with the hope of changing God’s mind on whether something is sinful, is a waste of time.
So, back to the conversation with Political Sphere. He mentioned a quote by Desmond Tutu, also from this weekend, saying, “I would not go to a homophobic heaven. No, I would say sorry, I mean I would rather go to the other place.” The assumption here is that, because God makes some people “be” (ser) a certain way, God should be forced to accept behavior from them that He would not accept from someone He had not made to “be” that way. I’m thinking that someone bold enough to try to enforce such pronouncements on God is quite likely choosing to go to “the other place.”
So we were talking about the uselessness of making the assumption that some people can’t control their particular behaviors, and therefore we as a society need to embrace those people along with their behaviors and simply stop allowing those behaviors to be called wrong. And we came up with a string of analogies.
He said, “I don’t want the world to be gluttonophobic. I may someday come to control my urges, but in the meantime, the world has to accept that I must eat all I want.” Have I mentioned that Political Sphere is a giant? He has over 200 pounds of lean body mass—which requires a fair amount of sustenance, but is not the problem. It is the non-lean body mass that is the issue, and he would probably need to lose a notable amount to fit the Superman profile. (As his mother, I still think he’s adorable in a very large teddy bear kind of way, but I do want him to live a long and healthy life.) Does he eat too much? Maybe, but who has the right to judge? Applying the Desmond Tutu logic, people who “are” gluttons should be treated exactly the same way as “non-gluttons,” without any judgment of their behavior, because it’s right for them; it’s who they “are.”
I had written a similar analogy using kleptomania (which I’m realizing right now is not included in the Defense of Marriage collection—maybe I’ll print it here in the future on a quiet day). Political Sphere remembered that the specific point of that piece was the absurdity of the way the APA removed same-sex attraction from its list of mental disorders. But his point simply relates to the absurdity of accepting any behavior a person doesn’t have control over, which could become a long and sordid list.
And then we talked about the big news of the day in court. A certain attorney showed up at court Monday morning (in the morning!) drunk. And in his inebriated state he failed to recall that he was carrying his gun with him—into the courthouse. He was arrested and by now is on his way to rehab. The case scheduled that day, along with all his cases, will be turned over to other attorneys, causing a fair amount of upheaval. The best case scenario for this man is the possibility of deferred adjudication on the drunk and disorderly conduct charge, depending on his success in rehab. But that might not be possible because of the felony charge of carrying a gun into a place where it was not allowed. (I’m uncertain whether there was a screening at the door, as in the downtown courthouse where I’ve served as a juror, or whether he got in, was found to be drunk, and the gun was found on him after that point.) It may be that the felony charge will prevent him from ever practicing law again. He’s a prominent person in the small-town community, so this likely made the local nightly news and will show up in a state bar journal. He has caused himself some serious harm.
But is this his fault? As Political Sphere pointed out, the man is alcoholic (using the word “ser”), so he can’t help it. He has the urge to drink alcohol, and who are we to judge whether that’s wrong for someone who is an alcoholic person? Should we not have different definitions of wrong behavior for people who are alcoholics? Their behavior can’t be expected to be the same as someone who is not an alcoholic, after all. So, for alcoholic lawyers, they should be accepted in court drunk on a Monday morning. And as for the gun carrying, no one really thinks he intended to cause harm with it; it was just a result of alcohol-caused stupidity, which is totally different for someone who is alcoholic than for someone who is not. As Bill Clinton would say, “It depends on what the meaning of the word is is.”

Monday, July 29, 2013

Family Superpower

I spend a lot of time with youth and young adult literature. Many of these feature young people with special powers, or at least special skills: magic (Harry Potter), electrical powers (Michael Vey), psychic control of objects (Freakling), wind (The Goose Girl), archery and strategy (Ranger’s Apprentice and Hunger Games). A young person goes about life thinking he/she is normal, or even less than normal, and then gets thrust into extraordinary circumstances that require using the newly discovered special skills.

There’s something fairly positive in the message that everyone has value, and everyone is important and special in some way. You just need to find your talent/purpose/superpower to benefit mankind.
I have been considering the idea that, in the ordinary real world we live in, some of us have significant advantages, just because of a connection to what has for millennia been ordinary: growing up in an intact, loving family.
The social data continues to grow, all of it showing advantages to children raised in intact families with married mother and father. I’ve written about the value of family, mothers, fathers, and marriage many times (a good starting list is in the April 23, 2012 post “More on Marriage”). I’ve written a few times (see “Family Ties to Economics” December7, 2012) about the well-established formula for preventing poverty:
1.         Don’t have sex before age 20.
2.         Don’t have sex until after marriage.
3.         Stay married.
4.         Obtain at least a high school diploma.
But what if there is an additional formula, not just for avoiding poverty, but for likely greater success? Last year I wrote  about Charles Murray’s book Coming Apart, which described four founding principles: industriousness, honesty, marriage, and religion. These were agreed upon as essential virtues by all the founders. They are agreed on as virtues today generally in the most successful areas (Murray referred to them as the SuperZips, identifying certain zip codes). The upper middle class adheres to these principles, and is thereby perpetuating success generation after generation, while lower middle class and lower class areas (by income and education) lack religious commitment, intact families, honesty, and all the behaviors that prevent decay.
As I write about at the Spherical Model, the answer to greater success is what it has always been for thriving civilization: strictly live the civilizing principles (essentially the Ten Commandments) and value family. Family is the way the civilizing principles pass from generation to generation. Schools can’t do it, especially without the support of the home. Government can’t do it. Without family, even the churches can’t do it.
I have a story, from almost two decades ago, that shows the passing on of the values. It was when our second son was in I believe fifth grade (still in public school at that point), and they were going through the first iteration of basic sex education. I had been to the school and reviewed the curriculum and talked with the school nurse ahead of time. While I would have preferred handling this entirely at home, this was before I became a homeschooler, and I felt satisfied with the way the school was teaching the information (family values included in that rather civilized corner of the country). Economic Sphere, as he frequently did, was excited about new information, and started a series of “did you know…” quiz questions when he got home. One of the surprising pieces of information was that children could be born even when their parents weren’t married. So we had a teaching moment.
Back in the day, our boys learning
superpower skills from their dad
At that time there was a young woman from our church, age 17, I think, who got pregnant and was going through the natural consequences. She was repentant, and wanted to repair her life and set things right. The young man was going off to college in another state, and they realized they did not want to be married. So she worked through the possibility of giving up the baby for adoption, a difficult decision for a young woman. Consulting with her parents, she concluded that placing the child with a married couple who had the same religious beliefs as her family would be best for the baby.
Even with that best-case scenario, the decision was heartbreaking. Then it was made more so when the young man’s parents insisted that, if she was going to give up the baby, they would adopt it, because letting go of a grandchild was unacceptable. In that state, they had the right to override the mother’s decision about who should get to adopt her child. She didn’t want them to raise her child; they might be loving grandparents, but they hadn’t done so well at raising the baby’s father, and she really wanted her child raised in her religion. So she chose to keep the child.
She had loving parents who helped out for several years, allowing her to live with them as needed while she went through nursing school so she could support herself and the child. At the time of the conversation with my son, the decision was made to keep the child, and I believe the child had been born. Economic Sphere and I talked about how the child would be surrounded by people who loved him: both parents would be involved, and all four grandparents. But that child would never have the opportunity to live in a home with both parents at the same time.
It was a major “aha” moment. The starkness of that lack of both parents in the home was very clear—and practically unthinkable. Any child could see that you need both a father and a mother. No other arrangement fills the child’s needs.
Because of the way we lived, and because of the clarity of contrast, we had that opportunity to pass along essential values to a son at a young age—so the decision about risky behavior was made years before teenage hormones could interfere with the brain. That is the power of families. Teaching moments like that come up day by day through the years, continually building the power.
I don’t want single mothers and fathers to feel worse about their situation. They may want the best for their children as much as married mothers and fathers. And there is nothing that says they can’t succeed. There is simply the fact that the odds are against them. Church, neighborhoods, community organizations like sports leagues and scouts can help make up for deficits in single parent families. But only if the social capital cost isn’t overwhelming. In the better neighborhoods, the SuperZips that Charles Murray illustrates, the few exceptions to intact families are easily floated aloft with the strong families. But in the already struggling neighborhoods, there’s not enough social capital to make up for the overwhelming deficit.
The idea that a marriage can always break up if things get tough is a tempting escape. One of the strongest incentives to work on a marriage and make it better comes from growing up in families that stayed together. I find myself feeling grateful that all three of my children married people who came from such families. Mr. Spherical Model and I both came from such parents. And grandparents. And great-grandparents. Our tradition of lasting families is not a guarantee that families will always last, but it is an extra power.
If you want to give your children even more power, practically a superpower in today’s world, save sex for marriage; choose wisely who to marry, stay married forever, and take your children to church with you. And then let your children know the value of the gift you’re giving them, so they will value it in the generations to come.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Education Collection


This past month, upon reaching the 400th post milestone, I did a collection of “best of” posts (part I, part II, part III), mainly related to the three overlying spheres of the Spherical Model. That left out some specific topics. So I followed up with the Defending Marriage collection. Today I'd like to add the Education collection.
If you know me, you know I spent ten years homeschooling my children. When I first started homeschooling, I felt so strongly about the decision that I thought it would probably be right for everyone who could possibly do it. I’ve modified somewhat over the years. Homeschooling is a lifestyle choice, and it takes energy and organization. Mostly, though, it requires a personality that gets excited about learning and helping others learn. That was natural for me, which made homeschooling amazingly fulfilling to my life—while it was also exhausting. I’m so glad we did it. But if someone knows about themselves that they don’t have the personality for it, what they really need to do is recognize their responsibility to see to the upbringing and education of their own children and see to it they provide the best opportunities they can manage. So I don’t as a rule proselytize toward homeschooling, although I’m often a resource for people thinking about trying it.
My friend Paige shared this homeschool field trip photo from 2008
However, after the election last fall, I came to recognize a greater urgency about parents seeing to their children’s education. Some of that comes from the intrusion of the federal government into every aspect of our lives, and the needed resistance to Common Core or any other centrally planned curriculum. Some of the change comes from the real frustration we face locally. Here in one of the most conservative states, in a part of town where conservatives dominate, where schools are considered (by someone else’s standards, not mine) to be high performing—here, of all places, you would expect the school board to reflect the parents and their values. But this election completed the turnover so that seven out of seven board members are moderate to liberal. They consider their constituencies to be the teacher organizations and the businesses that benefit from school spending (builders, curriculum providers, for example).
If in such a place we cannot guarantee that parents are the ones to respond to, then I have no hope for the efficacy of the public school system. Alternatives must take a greater role: private schools, charter schools, homeschools, online schools. Maybe there are alternatives we haven’t even discovered yet. But I do say, louder than I used to, that the federal government has absolutely no business sticking its nose into the education of my children and grandchildren. And state and local public schools have failed to prove that public school has a better purpose or outcome than providing the minimum skills for those whose parents can’t or won’t provide basics necessary for functioning in society.
So, I’m collecting the posts I’ve written related mainly to education. This includes a series of related posts this past March:
3-28-2011 What Works for Schools 
4-7-2011 Commencement  
5-7-2011 Public School Economics Lesson    
5-10-2011 New Paradigm for Education    
7-20-2011 What Make IQ So Racist?  
10-26-2011  Parental Rights   
10-2-2012 Local, Local, Local  
10-3-2012 The Priorities Question, School Board Part II   
11-12-2012 Paradigm Shift Underway  
3-15-2013 Natural Feeding and Teaching   
3-18-2013 Education vs. Indoctrination   
3-20-2013 Skeptical of Accreditation  
3-22-2013 Parental Right to Educate  
3-25-2013 Oppression through Education  
4-5-2013 More on CSCOPE  
4-15-2013 Homestyle Education, Part I  
4-17-2013 Homestyle Education, Part II  
4-20-2013 Homestyle Education, Part III  
4-22-2013 Homestyle Education, Part IV  
5-17-2013 You Might Be Living Under Tyranny If…, Part II (Romeike update)    


If you’re Texas local, and you’re even considering the possibility of homeschooling, Texas Home School Coalition is holding its annual convention next week, August 1-3. Full info here: http://thsc.org/events/convention/   The theme this year is Standing Firm. It will be, as usual, at the Waterway Marriott in The Woodlands, about an hour north of Houston, just off I-45. The most it will cost is $35 per adult for non-THSC-members at the door. A good deal. I feel nostalgic thinking about the good things I’ve learned at past conventions, and some of my favorite book and materials shopping as well.