Thursday, February 12, 2015

Confusion among the Courts


It has been an interesting week in Alabama. A federal district judge had decided that the state of Alabama was not allowed to keep the definition of marriage it has always had—that it must change from the family forming purpose of permanently joining a man and a woman to a recognition of any two people currently in a sexual relationship. Of course the judge, Callie Grenade, didn’t word it that way. She referred to the unfairness of “banning” homosexuals from marriage, even though Alabama law (nor in any state) prevents homosexuals from marrying the opposite-sex person of their choice. And certainly over the centuries many have.
The judge had recognized that there would be appeals, and also that there was a strong possibility some questions would be settled by the US Supreme Court this term, within the next few months. So she had allowed for a stay of implementing what she declared to be the new law.
But SCOTUS saw fit to take up this issue, quickly, and rule 7-2 that the stay was not allowed, and Alabama must go ahead and start issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. (More about the reasoning, and the strong dissent in a moment.)
But Alabama Supreme Court Justice, Roy Moore (the same one who stood up against SCOTUS by refusing to remove the Ten Commandments from his courtroom some years back) instructed Alabama officials not to issue the licenses.[*] He said,
Effective immediately, no probate judge of the state of Alabama nor any agent or employee of any Alabama probate judge shall issue or recognize a marriage license that is inconsistent with Article 1, Section 36.03, of the Alabama Constitution or § 30-1-19, Ala. Code 1975.
There are still cases pending. There is reason to assume a state does have the ability to define terms in a standard contract such as marriage. For officials in the state, the question is, do we obey the state supreme court or the federal circuit judge? Hmm. The people of Alabama elected Justice Roy Moore, but they did not elect an appointed federal circuit court judge, nor did they elect any of the SCOTUS justices. Also, federal courts under these circumstances are supposed to be applying current law in a particular case; they are not intended to set precedent.
But officials are torn; some counties are offering the marriage licenses to same-sex couples, while some counties are not. Confusion is the key word for the day.
But if there is a good chance the licenses would be declared null and void just a few months down the road, wouldn’t there be less confusion by waiting? SCOTUS is causing the confusion.
In Justice Clarence Thomas’s dissent (joined by Justice Scalia), he refers to patterns of the court in the past, leading to the expectation that there would be a stay in implementing the change, as Alabama requested. He listed several cases where SCOTUS had granted such a stay:
When courts declare state laws unconstitutional and enjoin state officials from enforcing them, our ordinary practice is to suspend those injunctions from taking effect pending appellate review. See, e.g., Herbert v. Kitchen, 571 U. S. ___ (2014); see also San Diegans for Mt. Soledad Nat. War Memorial v. Paulson, 548 U. S. 1301 (2006) (KENNEDY, J., in chambers) (staying an injunction requiring a city to remove its religious memorial).
Recently the Court had chosen not to stay, but those cases were following the Court’s refusal to take up the cases, last fall. At that point, while a stay still would have been useful and respectful to the states, there wasn’t an expectation of a permanent resolution in the near future. Now, after the circuit courts had disagreement, and the Court decided to take on the cases, there is an expectation of resolution in the near future, and the stay would therefore be expected and normal. Yet the Court went against pattern, and against respect for the State of Alabama, and refused the request for a stay.
Thomas adds,
Today’s decision represents yet another example of this Court’s increasingly cavalier attitude toward the States…. I would have shown the people of Alabama the respect they deserve and preserved the status quo while the Court resolves this important constitutional question.
What is a state to do when the Court inserts itself disrespectfully in an unresolved issue? Particularly when the issue to be resolved is whether a state has the right to do what states have always done? One could assume that the state might do just as Alabama did: ignore the federal edict and assert its state sovereignty.
There’s a bill in the Texas legislature right now with a similar purpose. It’s Texas HB 623, “relating to the funding, issuing, and litigation of certain marriage licenses (preventing officials to grant same-sex marriage licenses against Texas constitution and law).[†]
Texas, as many other states, strengthened existing defense of marriage laws by placing the definition of marriage in the state constitution—which meant that it could not be overturned by federal courts or legislation without directly challenging the sovereignty of the state. Most of the 37 states (I think that's the latest count) where same-sex “marriage” licenses are granted, have had it imposed on them even after the citizens of the states have voted to protect the traditional definition of marriage.
If the federal government derives “its just Power from the Consent of the Governed,” as we’re reminded in our Declaration of Independence, and neither the people nor the people’s representatives have changed the laws, what do the states, or the people, do when a law change is nevertheless imposed on them? Stand up. Stay strong. Refuse to give in. Ignore.
Some smaller states might fear to stand up. That’s why it’s important for a state the size and strength of Texas to stand up. To dare the federal government to invade the state and force submission. What are the odds that the US Military would invade Texas and enforce unjust laws?
We’ve had a Civil War before, and the resistors lost. But the pro-slavery South was out of alignment with the Constitution, which is based on natural God-given rights to life and liberty. If the resistors are standing up for state’s rights, religious freedom, and millennia-old beliefs about the value of family to civilization, will the military engage in a civil war over that?
We won’t know if we don’t stand up and give it a try.
No, I don’t want any kind of violent reaction. But what I trust is that, when you’re in the right, when you’re in alignment with the Constitution, and with God’s law, the good people of America will not violently react to that. They will say, “Oh, the people of Texas really mean it. Maybe we should think long and hard about the principles involved here.” And when thoughtful people think through the principles that lead to freedom, prosperity, and civilization, they choose those outcomes over the alternatives of tyranny, poverty, and savagery.


[*] A story about this news contains both Justice Thomas’s dissent and Judge Moore’s declaration: “Confusionin Alabama as State Judge Fights Supreme Court After It Allows Same-Sex Marriage,” February 9, 2015, TheBlaze.com.
[†] A story on this bill can be found at "Texas Rep Introduces Bill to Defend Traditional Marriage and StateSovereignty,” January 11, 2015, Breitbart.com.

Monday, February 9, 2015

Meeting a Freedom Fighter

This past Saturday we had a special speaker at our local tea party meeting. It was Rev. Rafael Cruz, father of Senator Ted Cruz. It’s the second time I’ve heard him in person, but this time was a smaller group, with more time. He’s a confident speaker, able to go on for an hour or two without notes. And he does probably a hundred or so such speeches a year.
Rev. Rafael Cruz
photo from Cypress Texas Tea Party
Rev. Cruz loves freedom. He was born in Cuba, but he makes sure you know he’s not a Cuban-American; he’s an American born in Cuba. As I recall his story, he escaped from Cuba during the early Castro regime, with $100 sewn into his clothes, and nothing else. But America is the land of the free, and he was able to prosper here, and set up circumstances for his son to get even more education and success.
He tells his son (I’ve heard Ted Cruz repeat this) that he had America to flee to; if we lose our freedoms here, where would we have to go?
He’s a strong defender of the Constitution, and structured his talk on the part of the Declaration of Independence about protecting life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness—pointing out that the order of those three things is the priority. Life has to come first—and he points out the most vulnerable are at the beginning and ending of life. Liberty is necessary, or else you’re a slave. There’s no guarantee of happiness, only a guarantee of the freedom to work for it, to pursue it in the way we choose.
As a pastor, it’s not surprising that he recognizes we live in a unique place—founded on the word of God, founded by religious people, seeking to live the word of God.
He’s a huge supporter of his son, which is understandable. He started with an anecdote following Senator Cruz’s election. Chris Wallace had asked him something like, “Are you going to Washington to join the club?” And Cruz answered, “No. I’m going to kick down the door, tear down the curtains, and auction off the silverware.”
He told some interesting background about his son’s growing up that I hadn’t heard. As Ted was entering high school, he was introduced to a leader of the American Enterprise Institute who got him reading classics. From there, Ted, in a group of five, formed what was called the Constitution Club. They memorized the Constitution. They toured the state, doing Rotary Club lunches and other forums. They would write the Constitution on several blackboards while people were eating. Then they would give speeches on free market economics.
A young Ted Cruz gave some 80 such speeches during his high school years. That had to be excellent preparation for later speaking before the US Supreme Court on behalf of the state of Texas while he was solicitor general.
I can’t think of a better high school preparation for someone serving this country. By raise of hand, how many of our elected officials have ever memorized the Constitution? Even the Preamble (we had our homeschoolers memorize it). Can they explain free market economics at least as well as Ted Cruz could in high school? That ought to be a requirement—if we could quantify it somehow as a standard.
During the Q&A I got to ask about the senator’s possible presidential ambitions. Just the night before I’d read something about the formation of a SuperPAC, which is often viewed as an exploratory preparation for running. Rev. Cruz said that the SuperPAC was formed in order to help a number of people in last November’s election, so that was its purpose and timing. However, he did acknowledge that many people have asked Senator Cruz about his willingness to run, and he says the Senator is spending some time seriously considering, and praying and discussing with family, whether he should run. And we can expect a decision one way or another in the next 30-60 days.
I got this button at the Texas GOP Convention last June,
just in case I need it someday
Over the weekend possible candidate Governor Rick Perry impolitely pointed out that we’ve tried a first-term senator without executive experience, and that hasn’t worked out so well. Ouch! Personally, I normally prefer governors, who have executive experience. I’m interested in learning more about Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana, and Gov. Scott Walker of Michigan. There may be others. Gov. Perry isn’t my favorite, but he’s light years ahead of what we’ve been experiencing. Gov. Jeb Bush has disqualified himself by supporting Common Core and amnesty; that makes him a “progressive,” which would appeal to Democrats, except for the Bush name. So he’s pretty much unsupportable for either party. That’s of course why the media claims he leads the polls.
I’ve liked a lot of Gov. Christie’s better moments, but I’m concerned that at heart he’s not fully conservative, but so far I haven’t written him off; I’m just not rooting for him. I have similar feelings about Senator Marco Rubio—who lacks the executive experience as well, and has some explaining to do about his immigration reform ideas (which have sounded like amnesty), but I’m willing to give him a listen, since he’s been good on many other issues. Senator Rand Paul has a lot to recommend him, especially on economics. But, while he’s not his father, his foreign policy is too isolationist for a world this dangerous, so I’m concerned but haven’t written him off.
But Ted Cruz—he lives and breathes the principles of the Constitution. The Constitution leads to freedom, prosperity, and civilization—every time it’s tried. We need someone willing to try it. We can’t afford any “compromise” that just sinks us slowly into tyranny. We need restoration of the brilliant American experiment in limited government.
While I’m satisfied with Senator Cruz as my Senator, I also recognize he has a backbone and ability to articulate truth in ways we are much in need of. As for previous experience, he has served in significant positions and done them well. No floating along voting “present” and agitating community organizations. Perry’s implied comparison of Cruz and Obama is pretty ridiculous. They are polar opposites.
I’m in favor of as strong a contrast as we can get with Clinton (or the Clinton-like alternative, if such a thing should materialize), who misspent her youth immersing herself with Marx and Alinsky.
But, speculation about presidential candidates is more of a sport than a solution. Rev. Cruz pointed out that what really matters is what happens when we leave that room. Do we share our ideas with others? Do we become precinct chairs (yes—as a matter of fact, our little tea party group has worked toward that goal pretty successfully the past couple of years; I am one)? Do we run for city council and school board? We need conservative Constitutionalists at every position from the bottom to the top. And every one of us needs to speak louder and let our representatives know what we expect of them as our employees.
So much to do! It’s a blessing we have a clear voice like Rev. Cruz inspiring and encouraging us.

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Higher Higher Education Costs


In the State of the Union address last month, one of the little candy toss-outs was free tuition at community colleges. We’ll tackle that in a minute. But in the follow-up interviews the president did with YouTube stars (go ahead and debate the appropriateness of that among yourselves), he was trying to explain how valuable politicians are. He said this:
Well, basically, politics is just -- how do we organize ourselves as a society? How do we make decisions about how we're going to live together? So, young people care about how college is paid for. Well, the truth of the matter is, the reason we even have colleges is that at some point there were politicians who said, ‘You know what? We should start colleges.’
Dating back to Abraham Lincoln, who started something called the land-grant colleges. He understood that government should invest in people being able to get an education and the tools to succeed. You guys are going to be the ones who are using these colleges and universities, and if they are not getting enough funding from government, and your tuition goes up, and you've got more debt, you're the ones affected. So you'd better have a voice and know what's going on about who's making decisions about that.
Politicians thought up colleges? As far back as Abraham Lincoln? What an invention!
Except that, I thought I remembered from an Iberian Culture class (back at the private university I attended) that the first university was created in Spain, in Salamanca. I didn’t remember a date, so I did a quick Wikipedia search. Salamanca dates to 1218, founded by the Catholic Church. It was among dozens of medieval universities in Europe (and not the first, although nearly so). Cambridge, in England, predates it by nine years.
Old Library, University of Salamanca
founded 1218, photo from Wikipedia
Other parts of the world lay claim to even earlier universities: Plato’s Academy, Athens, 387 BC; Najing University, China, 258 BC; Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt, 988 AD. Although the European ones might be the first degree-granting ones.
Meanwhile, I came across an article in my alumni magazine about some of those early universities and what they taught—the liberal arts: grammar, rhetoric, logic, arithmetic, geometry, music, and astronomy. This is from “The Crossroads of Learning,” by John R. Rosenberg, dean of BYU College of Humanities, in BYU Magazine Winter 2015:
What we call the Renaissance, what we celebrate as the beginning of modernity, was actually a rerun, a 15th- and 16th-century sequel of a remarkable unfolding during the 12th and 13th centuries. In the luminescence of what we incorrectly call “the dark ages” sprouted one of mankind’s great creations, one that has endured 800 years and, gospel-like, has spread to every nation: the university.
Pretty much without exception, these universities were not government inventions, but church or otherwise private creations. And the concept of higher education greatly precedes the creation of the United States. We could even say that it was the higher education level of the founding fathers that made it possible for our Constitution to be created.
Abraham Lincoln, himself, studied law. The system was different then, but he still went through some sort of private higher education in order to enter his profession, well prior to becoming president and working out the Morrill Act in 1862 to create the land-grant system—which is what president Obama referred to. That was where states received (at the benevolence of the federal government) grants of federal land within their boundaries that were to be used for the building of colleges.
Colleges didn’t suddenly come onto the scene at that point. Colleges were all private before that. Colleges remained mainly private. A substantial portion—including all but one of the Ivy League schools—have always been private. States have used land grants to create colleges. More often state governments have acquired existing private colleges, turning them into state institutions.
Are there any federal government schools? You could give that designation to the military schools: West Point, Navy, Air Force. They have had special missions, and were funded by Congress. But all other government higher education is at the state and local level.
So that’s the history—somewhat different from Obama’s claim that higher education exists because of some politicians sitting around, going, “You know what? We should start colleges.”
The next thing to look at is whether higher education (with the possible exception of military academies) is within the proper role of government. What is that list again? Oh yeah, it’s in the Preamble of the Constitution:
We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union,
·         establish justice,
·         insure domestic tranquility,
·         provide for the common defense,
·         promote the general welfare [i.e., good for all citizens at once]
·         and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity,
do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Does it say “give free higher education to all citizens"? No, it does not. Can you screw that idea into one of those provided? Nope. It’s good for the general welfare if we have an educated populace, but education is a product you can purchase, individually, according to your own desires and needs, and according to your preferences. Getting government involved in making that a blanket bestowal stretches the list beyond the point of elasticity.
And what do we know—conceptually, even before the data proves it—about government getting involved in something beyond its role? It will cost more. It will be poorer quality. It will essentially do exactly the opposite of the stated goal.
There’s a quote by P. J. O’Rourke, on free health care: “If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it's free.” Ouch! We can restate that for college education: “If you think higher education is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it’s free.”
Let me give you some perspective. I was raised in a family where I was told people like us (comfortable lower middle class) don’t go to college; that’s for rich people. But I was around a lot of smart kids who told me otherwise. There were things such as scholarships. For a while I had the mistaken idea that a scholarship was only for the top single person in a school, and I was among a lot of smart kids in a very large school. (The top 10% of the highly rated school would have been about 65 kids.) But they encouraged me anyway. And it turns out that most hard-working bright students can get some sort of scholarship. I was one of those. I also worked summer jobs, and sometimes two summer jobs plus a Christmas break job. One of my jobs was as a waitress in a luncheon restaurant in a department store—paid about $1.10 an hour plus tips, which were customarily about 10% then. Yet it was enough. I got through college without debt, and without family help beyond the occasional phone bill and a few things from the pantry.
It’s still possible to get a scholarship, but it helps if you’re somehow “underprivileged” in ways that supposedly I was not. It is much more likely that you can get student loans. Government stepped in and made that possible. Mr. Spherical Model (and therefore, me, by marriage) had student loans—at the low-cost government rate of 9% thanks to Pres. Carter making that rate seem low—of under $20 by the end of graduate school, which took a decade to pay off.
Skip ahead a few decades, and tuition rates have skyrocketed—consistently outpacing the rate of inflation, and, more obviously, the rate of household income. Why? Many reasons, interrelated, probably. But be certain that it has coincided with government’s attempt to make college more affordable for more students.
Making college affordable for more means greater demand. When demand is greater, prices go up. That is a basic economic reality. Although sometimes quality goes down to spread the service to greater numbers. Sometimes costs go up and service goes down (like with government health care).
I don’t know if this “free community college” plan will result in more community college students. But if it does, the cost of educating them will go up, and probably the quality of community college will go down. Count on it.
I also don’t know what an edict from the emperor-in-his-own-mind means. Community colleges, when not private, are paid for by local taxes—usually not even state taxes, but at the city and county level. So what the president has just done has offered to place (pending Congressional legislation, if lawful) an enormous burden on communities that are already stretched to meet the education needs of their communities at relatively low tuition rates compared to larger four-year universities. Somehow the already deficit federal budget will “grant” tax money filtered through federal treasuries to local community colleges to help them make up the difference between low tuition and zero tuition—coming from the same people and businesses already being taxed.
It hasn’t worked with any other government project beyond the proper role of government. It won’t work in higher education. Take a look at “free universal high school” where inner cities are lucky to have only a third fail to graduate. (Suburbs graduate at rates about 20% higher; rates across the rural-urban spectrum are related to family strength.) The same problems that lead a huge portion of the public to choose poverty over free high school education will lead to an additional portion failing out of free community college. And the cost for the rest of us will be far more than without government intervention.
But if the president is trying to “buy” voters from among lesser educated non-thinkers who haven’t learned this reality yet, he’s gone to the right source.

Monday, February 2, 2015

No More Right Wing


I came across a discussion a week or so ago between Andrew Klavan and Bill Whittle of PJ Media, talking about how fascism isn’t right-wing. It’s socialism. [Video below.] I’ve been saying that for a while. It’s a good discussion, but I continue to think my three-dimensional Spherical Model is a more useful way to view ideas. I re-introduced the basic concept the last post of 2014.
So watch their 5-minute discussion, and think—if we’d all been taught the Spherical Model all along, there never would have been any confusion. And we’d be free from the comparison between Constitution admirers and Nazis. We’d also be free from the requirement to compromise between one level of tyranny and another. We could leave right and left-wing tyrannies to themselves and insist instead on freedom, prosperity, and civilization. We could go north on the sphere and stay there.


 

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Courts and Public Opinions

The Supreme Court reversed its October decision, wherein it decided not to rule on states’ being required by circuit court judges to change their definition of marriage to include same-sex couples.

Maybe you saw what I did there; I did not say states were being told it was unconstitutional to ban gay marriages—for several reasons: 1) the Constitution is silent on that issue, which leaves it to the states; 2) keeping the definition as it has been in most cultures during all the millennia of human history is not a ban, which would require taking something existing away; and 3) people need to be aware that a change in definition of terms for a particular contract is what’s going on, such that marriage would no longer include permanence, exclusivity, and the sexual act required for procreation, but would simply “honor” anyone in any sort of sexual relationship at the current time, regardless of society’s interest in such a relationship.
Anyway, the SCOTUS changed because there is now a split among circuit court rulings, which gave them impetus to rule sooner rather than later. We can expect a decision by late June.
I never like putting matters of basic right and wrong ordained by God into the hands of a few judges (mainly appointed for their leanings). But we can pray that a good decision on their part might be helpful. As president of the Family Research Council, Tony Perkins, said, “Lower court judges have robbed millions of people of their voice and vote on society’s most fundamental relationship—marriage.  There is nothing in the Constitution that empowers the courts to silence the people and impose a nationwide redefinition of marriage.”
So, this decision for SCOTUS to get involved happened Friday, January 16th. The previous Friday, January 7th, the 5th Circuit Court heard oral arguments on the cases before it, relating to Texas. An interesting group of amicus briefs was presented—against same-sex “marriage,” from adults who had been raised by same-sex parents. Their complaints ranged from sexual confusion, to fear of disagreeing with the same-sex “marriage” promoters (risking ostracism from family relationships), to subjugation to sexual predation—apparently unprotected by the parents, and possibly even enabled by those parents.
I find some of what these people suffered to be horrifying. Their testimonies are anecdotal. However, they represent much larger numbers who have feared to come forward. Going against the culture they were raised in puts at risk the relationships they have reason to value.
The prescribed claim being made about “same-sex families” is that children raised by same-sex couples differ in no particular way from those raised by heterosexual couples. It might look like a pleasant claim, but it’s unsupportable. Studies have generally compared such children to children raised by heterosexual unmarried parents—which have significantly poorer outcomes than children raised by their married mother and father. More evidence is coming out that, not only are these children not better off than other children lacking a mother or father; these children also have the addition of sexual confusion and other sexual-related problems (overly sexual at a young age, inappropriate sexual relationships with much older adults, promiscuity, prostitution).
If the question is what is best for the children, there is nothing about same-sex parenting that satisfies society’s interest.
I listened to a good part of the oral arguments [here]. The plaintiffs’ claim that there is a Constitutional right to same-sex “marriage” fails to identify what marriage itself means. Their claim is that a minority group cannot be discriminated against by denying them marriage. This argument fails, because marriage laws do not prevent any homosexual person from getting married to a person of the opposite sex. Many homosexuals do that very thing; it’s the main way children come to exist for homosexual parents (adoption and in-vitro fertilization from a non-parent sperm donor being the other ways, because obviously a homosexual couple cannot produce offspring together).
So the argument further claims that there is a fundamental right to marry the person of your choice. But that simply isn’t so—and the different limitations are determined by the states. No state allows persons to marry someone already married, or someone under the age of consent without the consent of a parent (and then within a limited age range), and each state determines the level of consanguinity allowed (i.e., no states allow brother/sister marriage, and most disallow first cousins from marrying, maybe even second cousins). While the plaintiff’s law team made a show of reason and case law, their argument boils down to, “You have to call homosexual relationships equivalent to heterosexual marriage, because they want that, and you’re just being mean.” It’s emotional, not logical.
Some of the questioning of the defense dealt with various past cases and what each had contributed. Mostly they dealt with the question of whether and how marriage had been defined. A case concerning whether inmates could marry didn’t determine, for example, whether there was an inviolable right to marry, but related somewhat to whether a marriage could take place if there was no chance that the couple could consummate the marriage. Which really leads to a germane question that gets danced around: is it marriage if the couple does not intend to—and indeed cannot—consummate the marriage with the act that marriage is concerned with? You know the one—the particular kind of sex that can lead to procreation.
Some of the questions related to cases in which there is infertility or age impediments to procreation. But those are old, and answered; the law assumes that a man and wife with the appropriate genetics have the theoretical possibility of being fertile, and so the law does not interfere on that basis. However, failure to participate in the procreative sex act has been grounds for annulment or divorce pretty much universally; it’s a breach of the marriage contract.
What should be asked of same sex couples is, do you intend to behave as a married couple? i.e., engage in the required type of procreative act? And is it possible for you to do so with one another? If it isn’t possible, genetically, then what they are asking us all to do is pretend something is marriage that is not marriage. Our agreeing with them and proclaiming it so will not make it marriage; that will only disregard the underlying purpose of marriage.
Marriage may be much more than simply the sex act, but it must be at least that. Love is not required, but that particular behavior is. So to suddenly come up with a definition of “marriage” that excludes one of those basic essential details of what marriage means seems imprudent at best—and a hundred years hence will look foolhardy. There will not be (cannot be) progeny from same-sex couples, so the progeny of that generation will ask, “What were they thinking?”
Elder Dallin H. Oaks
photo from MormonNewsroom.org
In the wake of these marriage issues, there was a news conference this Tuesday, a relatively rare thing for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, asking for protections for freedom of religion. The whole twenty are worth hearing in context, but I’ll try to summarize the three parts. Sister Neill Marriott represented Church Public Affairs, and talked about respecting each other’s views and working together to understand one another. Elder Dallin Oaks, who has been a state supreme court judge, talked mainly about issues related to same-sex marriage—and the persecution that has come upon those who stand for traditional marriage. He pointed out that a people should be granted basic rights, and he enumerated things like being able to find employment and housing. But he also asserted the right for individuals to disagree on belief issues, and we should respect rather than stifle the freedom to believe differently. He was followed by Elder Jeffrey Holland, who spent much of his time concerning the larger questions of religious freedom, such as being able to choose whom to hire or what services to perform as a business, without coercion by government or pressure groups.
I thought they all three sounded reasonable and kind—extremely kind. There was no hate speech there. Nor was there any new doctrine or shift in policy. There was simply a declaration that the doctrine is what it is, and while we can respect that many people don’t believe the same way, we request, and firmly insist, that we have the right to our beliefs as well. We have been kind and respectful, and we ask for that in response.
Whatever the Courts decide, God will still have His will, and it’s up to us, in our personal ways, to go about aligning ourselves with that. Let’s pray that the Courts don’t make things harder for any earnest believers.

Tuesday, January 27, 2015

Tops and Middles

New data map from here
I had a casual dinner conversation over the weekend in which the top 1% came up. I pointed out that two of my dinner companion’s brothers were in the top 1%. She protested. I couldn’t remember numbers, but I kind of insisted it was anyone making over about $250,000 a year. She insisted it was in the several millions. I knew I was closer (and her brothers probably fit into at least the top 2%). But I was second-guessing myself and came home to look up the numbers. I was much closer than she was.

The numbers I came up with are from 2012, which isn’t very satisfying, but there you go.* [I found the information here.] Anyway, I’ve listed the top 1% in each state, from least to most. I also wondered about median income (per household) by state and various questions about the relationship between the top and the middle.
So here’s the data, followed by a couple of comments. (Delta is the difference between the top 1% and the median family income. The ratio is the top 1% divided by the median family income for that state.)
           Top 1% $300,000 or under                  Median in state                              Delta             Ratio Top 1%/Median
1.      Idaho               $274,000         $45,489           $228,511         6.0
2.      Montana          $280,000         $45,076           $234,924         6.2
3.      Arkansas          $283,000         $40,112          $242,888         7.0
4.      New Mexico    $286,000         $42,558           $243,442         6.7
5.      Wyoming         $295,000         $54,901*        $240,099         5.4*
6.      Alabama          $299,000         $41,574           $257,426         7.2
7.      South Carolina $300,000         $43,107           $256,893         7.0 

           Above $300,000 up to $400,000           Median in state                              Delta             Ratio Top 1%/Median
8.      West Virginia  $304,000         $40,196             $263,804         7.6
9.      Indiana            $307,000         $46,974             $260,026         6.5
10.  Mississippi      $309,000         $37,095*            $271,905         8.3*
11.  Kentucky         $311,000         $41,724              $269,276         7.5
12.  Iowa                $316,000         $50,957               $265,043         6.2
13.  Maine              $322,000         $46,709              $275,291         6.9
14.  Nebraska         $329,000         $50,723              $278,277         6.5
15.  Wisconsin        $334,000         $51,059             $282,941         6.5
16.  Ohio                $334,000         $46,829              $287,171         7.1
17.  Oklahoma        $335,000         $44,312             $290,688         7.6
18.  Missouri           $335,000         $45,321             $289,679         7.4
19.  Louisiana         $335,000         $42,944             $292,056         7.8
20.  Hawaii             $337,000         $66,259*           $270,741         5.1
21.  Tennessee        $338,000         $42,764             $295,236         7.9
22.  North Carolina $338,000         $45,150             $292,850         7.5
23.  Arizona            $339,000         $47,826             $291,174         7.1
24.  Delaware         $339,000         $58,415             $280,585         5.8*
25.  Michigan         $340,000         $46,859             $293,141         7.3
26.  Nevada            $340,000         $49,760             $290,240         6.8
27.  Utah                 $340,000         $57,049            $282,951         6.0
28.  Oregon             $342,000         $49,161            $292,839         7.0
29.  Vermont          $349,000         $52,977             $296,023         6.6
30.  Kansas             $351,000         $50,241            $300,759         7.0
31.  South Dakota   $352,000         $48,362            $303,638         7.3
32.  Alaska             $354,000         $67,712*           $286,288         5.2
33.  Rhode Island   $359,000         $54,554             $304,446         6.6
34.  Georgia           $365,000         $47,209             $317,791         7.7
35.  Florida             $367,000         $45,040             $321,791         8.1*
36.  New Hampshire$375,000        $63,280*          $311,720         5.9
37.  Washington      $378,000         $57,573            $320,427         6.6
38.  Pennsylvania   $387,000         $51,223             $335,777         7.6
39.  Texas               $391,000         $50,740             $340,260         7.7 

            Above $400,000                                     Median in state              Delta             Ratio Top 1%/Median
40.  Colorado          $406,000         $56,765            $349,235         7.2
41.  California         $433,000         $58,328            $374,672         7.4
42.  Minnesota        $408,000         $58,906            $349,094         6.9
43.  Illinois             $413,000          $55,137            $357,863         7.5
44.  Virginia            $433,000         $61,741*          $371,259         7.0
45.  Maryland         $435,000         $71,122*           $363,878         6.1
46.  North Dakota   $455,000         $53,585             $401,415         8.5*
47.  New York        $511,000         $56,448             $454,552         9.1*
48.  Massachusetts  $499,000         $65,339*           $433,661         7.6
49.  New Jersey      $504,000         $69,667*           $434,333         7.2
50.  Connecticut     $642,000         $67,276*           $574,724         9.5*
51.  DC                   $688,000         $66,583*           $621,417       10.3*

 
I marked the median state level for top 1% (as many states below and above); it’s $340,000, which is the actual top1% for three states. The range of top 1%-ers goes from a low of $274,000 in Idaho, up to $688,000 in Washington, DC (not even a state, but an expensive US place to live).  

Doing some math fun, I notice that the range of 1%-ers from the lowest to median is only $66,000. The range from the median to the high is $348,000. So I wondered, where does $66,000 above the median land; I’m sure you were wondering that very thing. That’s $406,000, right where Colorado is. Forty states fit within this range. I’m thinking, then, that states that don’t fit within $66,000 of the median are outliers, exceptions. There are ten states plus DC in this group. California plus the DC to New York/Connecticut corridor, with North Dakota randomly tossed in.  

My chart also shows median income for all the states. I wanted to see if regular people have to make more in the same states as the top 1% need more income to reach their top status. There’s some correlation. Forty-five states have median household incomes under $60,000 a year. Those that don’t are all among the outliers requiring high incomes for their top 1%.  

There are a couple of lower outliers as well. Mississippi has the lowest median income, at $37,095, while it ranks tenth lowest for its 1%-ers; even with that low 1%-er ranking, the top earn 8.3 times what the median family earns.  

Wyoming has a midrange median family income of $54,901, while ranking fifth for its 1%-ers.  So cost of living is low, and it doesn’t take that much to get to the top. (Go into oil, except when it’s at $50 a barrel, like now.) And then you have a place like Hawaii, with a relatively low rank for 1%-ers, but a surprisingly high $66,259 for median family income—high cost of living, but not so much harder to reach the top.  

In general, it takes a lot of money to live in the coastal bastions of “progressivism.” And apparently a lot of people make good money in North Dakota as well—maybe because of the oil boom there. (Again, the data is from 2012—with boom underway and no oil price slump yet.) 

What the chart doesn’t tell us is what lifestyle looks like for the top 1% and the median family. I looked at the ratio to see how many years it would take a median family to earn what a top 1% family earns in a year. That tells us a little about disparity, but not everything.  

Look at my state of Texas. There’s opportunity to get into the top 1% (it’s within $66,000 of the median states’ top 1% range), but the standard of living for the median family in Texas is pretty good. It’s not an outlier with a 7.7 ratio, but it does seem to have a relatively high disparity, if you don’t know that a median family might be buying a house in the suburbs. In Connecticut, it takes the median family 9.5 years to make what the top 1% make in a year—and the cost of living (made worse by taxes) leaves the median family probably hopeless about home buying. 

As for the dinner conversation—I admit I was low-balling the estimate for top 1% earners. Mea culpa. But I was right in that the top 1% are pretty nearly regular people, probably living in nice suburban homes, maybe with some extra property. They could be business owners, or maybe professionals who’ve had time to build up their business over some decades. But they aren't what most of us think of as "filthy rich." They might have more freedom to travel and invest than many. But they’re not casually buying numerous mansions and yachts and private jets.  

If you think the top 1% are multi-millionaires (by income every year), then you’re mistaking them for the top .1% (1 per thousand) . Or maybe the top .01% (one per ten thousand). There aren’t that many of those, no matter how many you see in media. And even if you confiscate all the wealth from all those super-high earners, you don’t lift standard of living nearly as well as those people can by hiring and spending on their own. 

So, re-read the Ten Commandments, and notice that one about “Thou shalt not covet” (also here). Let go of class envy and the associated false misperceptions. And trust that there is enough abundance in the world and to spare for all who follow the principles of freedom, prosperity, and civilization.


* PS: This evening, while looking for something graphic to go with this post (which I used above), I find that CNN put out a story today with some updated data. I’m not going to redo my math, since that wasn’t my point. Suffice it to say, what growth there has been since 2012 has been top heavy. Where there was disparity, there’s now more. It’s more pronounced where “progressives” enact their policies.