Monday, October 24, 2016

Truth Be Told

A week or so ago I spent part of a post talking about Obamacare. Since news on it came out this past week, it might be time to do that in a little more detail.

The challenge I’m looking at is a matter of parallel realities. There are those of us who love truth, and prefer to face the truth and deal with it, even when it’s not ideal, rather than pretend a problem isn’t there.

And then there are those we might call relativists. They don’t like the truth. And they philosophically convince themselves that truth isn’t really a thing; it’s relative. Your truth might not be my truth. We all have our own realities.

If someone wants to live in a fantasy world, that is their choice. The problem comes when they start imposing their fantasy world on the rest of us.

There are stories this week about Obamacare and its serious problems, which show a lot of data, and ring true, because so many of us have been affected, or know many people who have been affected.

And these contrast with other stories about how Obamacare has fulfilled its promises, and has made major steps toward solving everyone’s health care issues in the country—which are at odds with the facts, the data, and the anecdotal stories all of us have encountered.

Let’s start with some facts. Guy Benson comments on a USA Today piece, collecting a lot of the information. This first chart, provided by USA Today, shows the average percentages of rate hikes in the various states.

Image found here

The best off states (all big-government bastions) still have hikes. Which means that Obama was not telling the truth about everyone averaging a rate cut of $2500. That hasn’t happened in any year of Obamacare; rates have always risen. Some states are rising half again as much—just this year.
As Benson describes it,

Based on that chart, only a small handful of states will have the supposed 'good fortune' of experiencing single-digit hikes.  The vast majority will experience cost surges in the double-digits, with roughly half of all states getting slammed with increases of at least 20 percent.  Time magazine reviews the eight states where consumes will suffer the most next year, where regulators have imposed rate jumps of at least 30 percent.  The piece's opening sentence says it all: "The Affordable Care Act is getting a lot less affordable for many Americans."
The reason for the hikes isn’t, in these cases, because insurance companies are greedy; the reason is that the companies are required to stay solvent, because otherwise they shut down and all their customers lose service. Which happens to be a side-effect of Obamacare predicted by the reality-and-data side.

Benson continues,

Meanwhile, many Arizonans find themselves in Obamacare's crosshairs, getting rocked by the double-whammy of soaring costs and dwindling-to-nonexistent choices.
Millions of Americans lost their coverage in 2013, the year it was implemented, contrary to Obama’s pledge. The losses continue. This year an additional million lost their coverage.

If you start with the original premise, the Affordable Care Act was to make sure that some 30 million who, at that time, were estimated to be without insurance could get it. The idea was that those who had coverage could keep it. Costs would be lower. Choices would be greater. And policies would cover more.
People who do math pointed out the impossibility of those claims. People who read the Constitution pointed out the loss of freedom—if your government can force you to buy a product, at ever increasing prices, what can’t they force you to do?

So here we are with this growing mess. The “open enrollment” for this year begins November 1st, so word about the price hikes and loss of choices ought to be front and center in the news.

Instead, Obama gives a speech in which he glowingly reports on his signature “accomplishment,” with mainly lies—or fantasies, if you prefer to believe your nation’s leader is only delusional rather than purposely deceitful.

A fact-checking piece by Melissa Quinn, for The Daily Signal, listed several of the statements that are pretty easily refuted by fact. Quinn lines up each of these statements against the truth. But, as an example, let’s take a look at number 5: “Most people today can find a plan for less than $75 a month at the HealthCare.gov marketplace when you include the tax credits that the government is giving you.”

Here is Quinn’s response:

Earlier this month, Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell said that consumers who purchase plans on the exchange and receive a subsidy may see monthly premiums of less than $75. The president echoed Burwell’s statement Thursday.
However, of the 17.3 million people who purchase plans sold in the individual market in 2015, 7.3 million received subsidies that lowered the cost of their health insurance. Another 10 million consumers did not qualify for financial assistance.
Those consumers, experts say, are going to be hit the hardest by premium increases. In Missouri, for example, one Kansas City resident will see his monthly premiums rise to $716 each month.
It would be nice to be able to compare like to like. How many of the uninsured prior to Obamacare are now insured at rates they can afford? How many who had insurance they were satisfied with before the ACA have lost it? How many now remain without coverage—at risk of the serious fine, which is less a burden to them than the cost of the “affordable” care?

My guess is that the negatives—loss of coverage, loss of their choice of doctors, and skyrocketing costs—affect more than the original number of those the law purported to help.

It is an axiom that when government goes beyond its proper role, there will be negative unintended consequences, and they will likely be the exact opposite of the stated purpose. So, affordable care means less care, and less affordable.

Glenn Beck has been doing a 4-part audio series this week on socialized medicine, calling Obamacare the “Lie of the Year.” This lie that has been spreading across the world and failing for decades.

There is a difference between coverage and care. It was government interference in the first place that caused insurance to become more than coverage for extraordinary expenses, and covered more everyday expenses, separating customer from the cost, and thereby raising costs, until it appeared that only those with insurance could afford basic care.


More government is not the solution. More free market—that is where the solutions are. Free market, combined with philanthropy for those who are truly in need and unable to pay. A good, generous people, with the freedom to be giving because they are in control of spending their own accumulated wealth—that is the way to provide everyone with needed care. 

Limiting freedom, coercion, redistribution—those are all the old, failed solutions that always lead to tyranny, poverty, and savagery. Speaking falsehoods or fantasies does nothing to provide care in the real world.

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Good Clean Fun

Sometimes life is about looking at the really good things, and tuning out some of the not so good or really bad.

I’ve learned that in eating. (Someday maybe I’ll do a food blog.) My limitations, because of food sensitivities, are extreme. Way beyond paleo. Social eating is troublesome; it usually consists of me doing some preventive eating beforehand (so I won’t starve), and then me standing around while others eat in front of me. Sometimes I get to eat a dry carrot stick or plain strawberry.

And yet, I find my food delicious, colorful, and usually satisfying. And I’ve been doing this long enough that my illness situation is what you’d call under control. I do a lot, mostly in private, to maintain my health. But because I do it, I am more free, and in many ways more healthy, than many people my age (upper 50s). I’m not overweight. My blood pressure hangs out around 110/70. And I’m mostly pain free. I was playing volleyball until three years ago (not especially well, but as a contributing player on the team). And I can get a lot done in the hours I’m awake and active.

There are additional restrictions in my life. We’re Mormon. We don’t drink alcohol, do drugs, smoke tobacco, or even drink coffee and tea. We don’t go to R-rated movies (provisos here; the movie rating system doesn’t determine our obedience, but that’s a guideline that describes our limitations relatively well). We don’t hang out at bars. We do a lot of family friendly stuff—even when the kids are not around.

The question used to come up a lot, with our teens and their friends, about this dichotomy between being good and having fun. And it was our goal to show them that being good is fun—more fun than being bad.

That’s the point of today’s post. Civilization isn’t a matter of restricting ourselves from a lot of normal behavior that we disapprove of. It is a matter of choosing—and making/keeping normal—a lot of behavior that fills our lives in better ways—giving us more happiness, more joy, even more fun.
A couple of examples showed up recently, in entertainment.

One is a new sitcom called Kevin Can Wait. It’s the story of Kevin Gable (played by Kevin James), who has just retired after 20 years on the police force—along with three of his buddies who also just retired. His attempts at enjoying retirement present comic situations—as do his interactions with his family.

I’m a long-time Kevin James fan. He’s funny, human, and generally clean, in an entertainment world that is typically otherwise. This show impressed me the first week. There’s something the college-age daughter wants to tell her father, and the mom advises her to wait until after church on Sunday, because then she’s got a few hours while her dad is trying really hard to be a better person.

It’s a casual mention—as though going to church on Sunday is a totally normal part of life. It is, for a majority of Americans, but these normal churchgoers are rarely portrayed in Hollywood entertainment, and even more rarely as normal people. So that was a plus.

The college-age daughter, Kendra, announces that she is engaged, and dropping out of school to support her future husband. The parents intervene and find a better solution. She can move back home, work part-time, and attend the local college. And the fiancĂ©, Chale (a British-accented sensitive type very unlike Kevin), is invited to live in the garage and pursue his goals as well. It’s a sacrifice for Kevin, who was going to use that garage apartment as a rental to supplement their income, and he ends up having to do some security work.

I wasn’t sure at first whether the engaged couple was moving into the garage, or just the fiancĂ©. But in a later episode, Kendra is complaining about sharing a room with her younger sister, and suggests that, because they’re engaged, it would make sense for her to move into the garage. Her dad says no. They’re engaged, not married. His house; his rules. And no one even thinks to argue further.

This is normal. More normal, more typical, than what is portrayed in most of our entertainment.

And the typical things that happen in the show are funny. In the second episode, Kevin has a shoulder pain that causes him to have to sleep on a different side, so that he’s facing his wife. She’s sleeping with her eyes partly open and only the white showing. She’s a very attractive wife (so maybe one detail not quite as realistic as the rest of us), but she looks pretty frightening that way. It was a funny moment in a show of one funny moment after another. It’s on Monday nights on CBS.

Another of my favorite shows is Studio C, which just started its seventh season. This is a comedy sketch show, similar to Saturday Night Live, with an ensemble cast. But absolutely clean. It’s available on BYUTV, if you get that in your TV lineup, or online at BYUTV.org. And their sketches are also available individually on their YouTube channel.

They started as an on-campus improv group. (Daughter Social Sphere knew one of them, when they were resident assistants the same year.) Then Matt Meese approached BYU Studios and pitched the idea of a sketch comedy show. And it turned out they could make a living doing this thing they did for fun.

Several of their sketches have gone viral online. One was soccer goalie Scott Sterling, whose face is what hits the ball—again and again. (That’s Matt Meese playing Scott Sterling.)

  

Another of their viral series was the three-part Hunger Games videos:

·         Peeta’s Song
·         Gale’s Song
·         Katniss’s Song

Can we all just admit, the Hunger Games world was very much in need of some comic relief?
In the comedy world, a couple of other options are BrianRegan, and Jim Gaffigan.

The question most often asked of comedians who do clean stuff is why? What makes them determined to do it that way? And they have to explain what ought to be obvious—there’s an awful lot of humor out there, in our normal lives, our family lives, among us human beings, that doesn’t require profanity, sexual innuendo (or explicitness), or anything degrading.

We can live in a civilized world and enjoy it. Who knew? Not only is it possible, it’s more probable to live happy, fun, joy-filled lives in the Civilization Zone than in the Savagery Zone.


And we don’t want to keep it a secret. As they say as a theme on BYUTV, let’s “share the good in the world.”

Monday, October 17, 2016

Discernment

Saturday before last I was at the local Tea Party meeting. We hear from candidates and speakers at these meetings. And then, at the end, we just discuss whatever is on our minds. One of the things on everyone’s mind that weekend was the audio recording of Trump saying vile things about women, which most of us have heard too much of, and too much about. One man brought up the subject, and he was pretty disgusted, and concerned that such comments could reflect badly on any Republican man.

A woman who attends regularly spoke up. She said men talk like that. She’s been married to a cop for several decades, and she hears that kind of talk all the time. It’s just talk. Locker room talk. All men do it.

The first man said, “I hope you don’t think we all do.” And our president, a good Christian man, agreed with him; they don’t talk like that—ever. The first man said maybe some of them talked badly in junior high locker rooms, but they’d all left that behind at about age 12.

I appreciated his standing up for good men. And I’m puzzled by the woman who thought that kind of talk is acceptable.

It is uncivilized. You cannot expect someone to lead people toward civilization if they are mired in savagery.

I grew up in a relatively civilized time and place. I rarely heard profanity spoken around me. I was an adult before I heard the f-bomb spoken in my presence. It was a coworker at my summer job, who used it frequently. It shook me, because it was so against propriety, and he didn’t seem to care. Without my making any comment, our boss reminded him not to talk that way in my presence. He tried, off and on, to control himself, but it slipped out anyway.

I don’t remember anyone talking locker room talk around me while I was young. And I grew up with brothers, and their friends, who made very little effort to make me comfortable around them, or to convince me they were anything but typical bad boys. But they wouldn’t have said things like that in my hearing. Even teenage boys knew, back then, not to do and say certain things in the presence of children and women. Outside of entertainment and reading, I have still had almost no one use that kind of profanity around me.

Trump is half a generation older than I am, so he ought to be aware of propriety, but he seems to lack that sensitivity.

Some of the conversation the week that followed has been about the sanctimonious former supporters who claim this audio from eleven years ago was a bridge too far. Now that they see who this man really is, they withdraw their support.

And then others point out that, among these shocked people are multitudes of women who have read Fifty Shades of Gray. Which is supposed to mean they do not have the moral authority to condemn Trump for his filthy talk. Some people even argue that, in Trump’s case, it is only talk, not actual sexual assault, like Bill Clinton committed. And then accusations from women start appearing, some of them credible.

Maybe some instruction about civilization is needed—again.

I have not read Fifty Shades of Gray. But I am an avid reader, so of course I have looked into what it is about. No, it would never be something I would choose to read. Not a chance. Among the many reasons is that it is purported to be a book encouraging combining sadism and sex, with neither commitment nor love—and leading the woman (and women readers) to believe that somewhere in that savagery, there might be some sort of exciting version of true love, which they yearn for. In other words, it is a lie—a very ugly one. You don’t find civilization by wallowing in savagery.

It is an equally ugly lie that men get to view women as objects, and that they are entitled to more objectifying sex acts against women if they are rich or powerful. Both of the main presidential candidates apparently believe this, and live out the belief. Former President Bill Clinton is at least as vile in his behavior toward women, and Hillary has attacked the women who have attempted to stand up for themselves and call him out.

There is no civilization there.

Among the discussion has been a fallacy aimed at Christians, about avoiding judgment. After all, we’re all flawed human beings. This is probably worth devoting a number of Sunday sermons or lessons to. But I’ll try to be brief here.

Judging is about unrighteously condemning a person—assuming you have that power instead of God. You can’t know a person’s heart, their efforts toward or away from the good, because you don’t know the total background that has led them to where they are. Judging, in this sense, is discarding a person as irredeemable, refusing to allow the atonement to apply in their lives.

There’s a better term for what is happening with Trump (or either Clinton): discernment.
Discernment is perception, understanding, insight. It is accurately judging based on a broad and deep body of evidence.

From my old Websters New World Dictionary, 2nd College Edition

Discernment is what we use when we decide who to date and marry. If you’re a teenage girl, it might be true that you don’t really know a person until you’ve spent time with them, but you still don’t get on a motorcycle behind a greasy, smelly stranger on the off chance he might turn out to be just the person you want to be father to your future children. (I once had this contrast put to me, when the answer to me seemed obvious, because I used discernment, but not to the foolish younger teen girl who took off with that guy.)

You use discernment to decide who to spend time with as friends, who to associate with in church and community.  

Discernment is how you decide who to hire. You collect the data—the resume, the portfolio, the recommendations. You interview. You don’t say, “Well, he talks about women as sex objects, he lies, he brags, and does other things I might consider unethical and would never do, but we’re all flawed and I don’t want to judge, so I’ll go ahead and hire him.” 

You don’t do that. You use all the information you can get, and then you use discernment to make a good hiring decision. An election is exactly that—a hiring decision.

Judging a person is between you and God—you’re telling God whether He should condemn a person, in this life and the next, based on your ideas of right and wrong. There are a lot of people about whom you can withhold judgment, people you can pull for to improve, to come to the side of light. But you still wouldn’t hire them, or invite them to date your daughter.

If you thought Trump was an ideal representative of the Republican Party, with its long-standing history of conserving liberty, prosperity, and civilization, until this audio leak—then you weren’t using discernment during the Primary process, or since.


If there’s one thing we need more of right now—at every level of the election, and in our news sources and entertainments—it is discernment.

Thursday, October 13, 2016

Voting and Econ Lesson

One of the best pieces I’ve read recently is Mike Rowe, theDirty Jobs guy’s response to someone who encouraged him to use his platform to encourage voting—to Get Out the Vote.

Mike Rowe
image from here


I wrote a piece about whether to GOTV just before the 2012 election, which seems even more necessary this year. I’m in agreement with Mike Rowe. Here is part of his response:

Thanks for the kind words. I appreciate it. I also share your concern for our country, and agree wholeheartedly that every vote counts. However, I’m afraid I can’t encourage millions of people whom I’ve never met to just run out and cast a ballot, simply because they have the right to vote. That would be like encouraging everyone to buy an AR-15, simply because they have the right to bear arms. I would need to know a few things about them before offering that kind of encouragement. For instance, do they know how to care for a weapon? Can they afford the cost of the weapon? Do they have a history of violence? Are they mentally stable? In short, are they responsible citizens?
And he continues:

Voting is a right, not a duty, and not a moral obligation. Like all rights, the right to vote comes with some responsibilities, but let’s face it—the bar is not set very high. If you believe aliens from another planet walk among us, you are welcome at the polls. If you believe the world is flat, and the moon landing was completely staged, you are invited to cast a ballot. Astrologists, racists, ghost-hunters, sexists, and people who rely upon a Magic 8 Ball to determine their daily wardrobe are all allowed to participate. In fact, and to your point, they’re encouraged.
The undeniable reality is this: our right to vote does not require any understanding of current events, or any awareness of how our government works. So, when a celebrity reminds the country that “everybody’s vote counts,” they are absolutely correct. But when they tell us that “everybody in the country should get out there and vote,” regardless of what they think or believe, I gotta wonder what they’re smoking.
What we need are better voters, so we don’t get the intolerable choices we got stuck with this election. He suggests:

I can’t personally encourage everyone in the country to run out and vote. I wouldn’t do it, even if I thought it would benefit my personal choice. Because the truth is, the country doesn’t need voters who have to be cajoled, enticed, or persuaded to cast a ballot. We need voters who wish to participate in the process. So if you really want me to say something political, how about this—read more.
Spend a few hours every week studying American history, human nature, and economic theory. Start with Economics in One Lesson. Then try Keynes. Then Hayek. Then Marx. Then Hegel. Develop a worldview that you can articulate as well as defend. Test your theory with people who disagree with you. Debate. Argue. Adjust your philosophy as necessary. Then, when the next election comes around, cast a vote for the candidate whose worldview seems most in line with your own.
He continues with a couple of paragraphs about the right and responsibility of informed voting. And then he concludes with this:

In the meantime, dig into Economics in One Lesson, by Henry Hazlitt. It sounds like a snooze but it really is a page turner, and you can download it for free.
So, thank you, Mike Rowe, for using your celebrity to share wisdom, yet again.

That’s two mentions, in one short piece of Economics in One Lesson, which I happened to start th anniversary edition from 1996. The original was written in 1946. It’s amazing that words written 70 years ago seem so current today.
reading a couple of days earlier. I’m only a few chapters into it yet, but he’s right that it is quite readable, and under 200 pages. It has been on my list of stuff to read for several years—and actually on my shelf, waiting to be read for a few months. I have a used paperback, 50

There’s a premise the book makes early on, explaining why so many economic efforts go awry. This is from page 1:

In addition to these endless pleadings of self-interest, there is a second main factor that spawns new economic fallacies every day. This is the persistent tendency of men to see only the immediate effects only on a special group, and to neglect to inquire what the long-run effects of that policy will be not only on that special group but on all groups. It is the fallacy of overlooking secondary consequences.
In this lies the whole difference between good economics and bad. The bad economist sees only what immediately strikes the eye; the good economist also looks beyond. The bad economist sees only the direct consequences of a proposed course; the good economist looks also at the longer and indirect consequences. The bad economist sees only what the effect of a given policy has been or will be on one particular group; the good economist inquires also what the effect of the policy will be on all groups.
Here at the Spherical Model we have a similar saying about unintended consequences:

Whenever government attempts something beyond the proper role of government (protection of life, liberty, and property), it causes unintended consequences—usually exactly opposite to the stated goals of the interference.
I’m sure I’ll want to refer to Hazlitt’s book more as I read to the end, but I think this is going to be a main theme. And I want to quickly apply it to one example: Obamacare, or the inaptly named Affordable Care Act.

When the Supreme Court was hearing oral arguments about whether the government had the power to compel citizens to buy a product or service, there was discussion about how healthy young people were getting away with lower costs, or going without insurance, which was unfair to older or chronically ill people. The only way to lower their costs was to bring in a lot of healthy people who would not need the coverage, to even out the risks, and the costs. There was an assumption that the government ought to have the power to even out life’s unfairness.

But, just as Hazlitt suggests, the group that needed lower cost insurance because they would make more use of it is only one group. If you focus only on the goal of solving their issue, you might end up doing harm to other—maybe every other—groups in society.

If there is a time for a person to choose to pay for health care out of pocket, it might be when that person is young and healthy. Such a person might still want catastrophic coverage, or might want to risk not having it. But if this young person is at the beginning of a career, and making only $15 an hour, he is probably not going to appreciate being forced to pay $1000 a month for coverage he doesn’t want or need, just because some older (and probably wealthier) person wants his coverage subsidized.

And, of course, as it turned out, you don’t get to keep your doctor; you don’t get to keep your coverage; and costs have skyrocketed—even for the group government was targeting to help in that SCOTUS conversation. (Michelle Malkin offer her personal experience in this piece.)

How did we get here? By electing leaders who get the attention of various factions by promising them things—and by voters who fall for it.


So, I’m with Mike Rowe: go vote, if you know what you’re doing. If you don’t know what you’re doing, stay away from the polls. If you want to get ready for future elections, read. Start with Hazlitt’s Economics in One Lesson.

Monday, October 10, 2016

Electronic Ballot Security

There’s good news and bad news concerning ballot security—which can, unfortunately, affect the outcome of our elections.

But in Harris County, here in Houston, we can feel pretty good about certain aspects of election integrity. 

This past Saturday, at our local Tea Party meeting, we heard from Ed Johnson of the County Clerk’s Office concerning ballot security here. Specifically, he was talking about the eSlate machine used here, and how they protect its integrity.
Ed Johnson, Harris County Clerk's Office
photo: Cypress Texas Tea Party


Can it be hacked? If everyone involved colluded, then possibly. But with the bipartisan safeguards in place, no.

How did he convince us? He began with a story.

Back in 1996 Duane Bohac, his friend from their college fraternity days, told him he was going to run for state representative. He was running against a 20-year incumbent. The incumbent had 15 voters registered at his home (people who didn’t live there), plus six more in his garage. This voter fraud was reportable, and those illegal voters were removed from the rolls, which is good. But it shows the propensity of that Democrat to engage in illegal voting tactics.

Early vote tallies showed Bohac up by about 1000 votes. But there were four precincts that reported very late—not until around 1:00 in the morning. After they reported, Bohac lost by 75 votes. They found hundred of over votes in those precincts—votes that have more than one candidate marked on the paper ballot, so they are not counted.

In 1998 Bohac ran again. This time he got alternate judges (Republicans, when the presiding poll judge is a Democrat) and poll watchers to watch what happened. The poll watchers followed the judges as they drove the ballot boxes to the central location for counting. As in the previous election, all but four precincts reported in a timely manner. The poll watchers followed these four as they drove around the 610 Loop (the innermost freeway circling Houston) until 1:00 AM. They watched them shaking the ballot box. Early counts showed Bohac leading. But these four precincts showed 400 overvotes, and Bohac got zero votes from these precincts. (Bohac eventually tried again and won; he is my state representative.)

Paper ballots are easy to manipulate. Remember the 2000 election with its hanging chads? Suppose someone with a moment alone takes a long sharp device—like an unbent paper clip—and pokes it through a whole stack of punchcards through the punch hole of the candidate they favor? Any ballot already voting for that candidate is left unchanged, but any ballot for another candidate is now an overvote—or possibly a confusing one with a hanging chad, which pretty much never happens when punching only one card at a time. In that election there were also entire precincts with zero counted votes for Bush, which is statistically highly unlikely, especially when you consider these "safe" areas were the ones where Gore asked for the recount. [Johnson only mentioned the hanging chads. The rest of this paragraph is from what I remember of that history.]

In 2000 County Clerk Beverly Kaufman was faced with a problem. Harris County has the longest ballot in the country (some say LA has a longer one, but Johnson says he still feels confident in making the claim). Much of this is because we vote for judges, and it’s a very large county with a lot of district courts. Anyway, Kaufman couldn’t find a ballot long enough to handle all of the races. Within two years she found the Hart System, which makes the eSlate machine we still use here.

The Hart eSlate Machine
used in Harris County

Since the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) in 2002, electronic voting has been required across the country. A federal commission must certify the equipment. The Election Assistance Commission was functioning well until Obama; he has refused to appoint anyone to the post, and it has gone defunct, so there have been no updates available, so it is still a slow and burdensome process.

Nevertheless, County Clerk Stan Stanart got our eSlate system to pass the federal regulations. The EAC test takes a year to complete, and costs the company $2 million. Then the system is submitted to states, which take another year for testing. Ours has passed both. HAVA gives money to the states to buy equipment that meets standards.

Johnson spent a fair amount of time going through the type of testing done. He used a number of detailed slides, so this report will only skim the surface, from my notes.

There is HASH testing, or code testing. They check to make sure no coding has been changed.

There is BOSS testing—Ballot Originator Software System. There is no connection to the internet, at any point. Ever.

There are two encryption keys between segments of the system. One is internal. One is external—on a thumb drive. The official (County Clerk) has to take it and plug it in. This is kept in a vault.

There is the Mobile Ballot Box (MBB), the memory card upon which the ballot is backed up. Votes are also kept in three places in the system; cheating would require changing all three locations somehow, without leaving a trace. The memory card is loaded into the JBC (judge's booth controller) machine. A security code identifies the card for each machine. This is tracked throughout the process.

There is security of the election equipment. When you press “cast ballot” on the eSlate machine, your vote is saved in three locations—with the timing of that vote and other identifiers. It is virtually impossible to change votes on a memory card and the other two locations.

There is Login and Accuracy Testing required by law, that takes a week. It uses people of both parties. They create a spreadsheet that includes every possible combination of votes on the ballot. The testers input, physically, each of these voting combinations. The outcome must meet the spreadsheet. This shows there is no tabulating error. Harris County has always passed this test.

For early voting, supervisors set up the polls, with the machines showing zero votes on the screen. They print this zero report to start, and at the end of the day they do another report. Equipment is locked, resealed—all seals are labeled with codes, which must match, to show that there was no tampering overnight. At the end of early voting, the machine is sealed, again with a coded seal. A constable delivers the machine to the downtown office. Seals are validated, and the machines are locked in a vault with the memory card still inside it.

There’s a second Login and Accuracy Test done by members of each party. This takes three hours on election night, with a high amount of security. It is completed just prior to the polls closing. Early voting tallying begins, but no results are available—to anyone, including those involved in the counting—until after the polls have closed, so that early voting outcomes have no influence on voters who haven’t yet voted.

At the polling place, machines arrive sealed, with codes on the seals, which are recorded. The zero tape is printed, to show that there were no votes on the machine prior to the start of voting. Each voter must show eligibility (ID), sign into the polling book—plus their name is written by the clerk on a voter list. The voter is sent to the JBC machine to get a code. They take their code to the voting booth and enter their code on the eSlate machine. The machines have a dial, which prevents errors that can happen on touch screens. No helper (language assistant, for example) can touch the machine—only the voter. The voter presses “cast ballot,” and a flag on the screen indicates that the voter was successful in casting the ballot, and the voter can leave the booth.

There are some similar machines that can print cast ballots. This removes the safety of a secret ballot, and these machines have a lower accuracy rate. So Harris County does not use them.

The individual votes cast can be printed—and are printed, by a hard-to-read dot-matrix printer. Stan Stanart still uses this, although the state has recently allowed an alternative laser printer version. But, once an election process is underway, Stanart doesn’t make changes, so this election will still use the dot-matrix printer.

Every recount done in the county has come out the same as the original count; the electronic voting system has a zero% error rate.

There are seven vendors selling electronic voting equipment nationally. It is our County Clerk’s opinion—and Harris County has been ground zero in preventing election fraud—that the HART system is the best.

I have no personal expertise to know whether this is true, but I have been a poll watcher and poll worker here a number of times. And I am persuaded that electronic voting prevents fraud, and I’ve seen the security procedures followed carefully at the polling places.

Ed Johnson told us (though it wasn’t news to us) that Democrats hate electronic voting. In the national effort to “turn Harris County blue,” they have two goals: do away with photo ID, and get rid of electronic voting.

Unfortunately, electronic voting can prevent counting errors, but it can’t prevent all other versions of election fraud.

Picture a voting place with no alternate judge or poll watcher. There may be people on the rolls that haven’t voted yet. The judge can put the voter’s name on the list, print out a code, and hand it to a friend to cast a ballot. If the person comes in and signs the book later, they still get to vote, and, unless there is a recount, no one will notice that person’s name twice on the voter list.

Or the judge might print out the code and cast the extra vote without even bothering to put a name on the voter list. At the place I worked as a poll watcher in 2012, there were 20 additional votes at the end of the day that were not recorded on the voter list. The presiding judge made no attempt to reconcile the error; she just shrugged her shoulders and assumed the clerks had failed to write the names that many times. That’s possible, but I hadn’t witnessed any failures. The difference in the election nationwide was about 10 votes per precinct. 

I did file the discrepancy in my report, but voter fraud is notoriously hard to prove. In some of the most egregious cases, the only outcome is to prevent that judge from being hired again.

The best prevention is to have an alternate judge and poll watcher in every polling place. Harris County has a pretty good program to train and recruit towards this end, but it’s still a challenge. And it’s not being done in many voting places around the country.


The good news, then, is that people in favor of free and fair elections are getting better technology to accomplish that. But the bad news is that people against free and fair elections will continue to find ways to disenfranchise the voters who disagree with them.

Thursday, October 6, 2016

What Freedom Looks Like

It seems natural to me that people would want to enjoy freedom. I don’t mean leisure time activities, or having great wealth so you don’t have to work. I mean freedom to make decisions about your own life and how you’ll spend it.

So I am puzzled by the large numbers of the population who choose less freedom. What is it they believe they are getting?

I don’t know the answer to that question. But I am always looking for better ways to explain the Spherical Model goals of freedom, prosperity, and civilization.

Back in January I wrote a post defining freedom, liberty, and some related words. It included a quote from Lincoln, showing he had thought about the definition of freedom, well enough to look at all sides and come to a conclusion based on principle. That truth was known in 1864, so it ought to still be known today.

I recently came across a piece written by Frenchman Benjamin Constant in 1816. This was in the decades following the American Revolution, the French Revolution and their various attempts at self-rule, and British movement toward a more representative parliamentary rule. The whole of the piece was on comparing the then-modern definition of liberty to the ideas used in ancient societies, which excluded individual rights. In the piece he has a description of liberty—a synonym for freedom—that I think we can still find useful.

I have used only Benjamin Constant’s words, but I turned it into a bullet-point list to make it easier to grasp:

First ask yourselves, Gentlemen, what an Englishman, a French-man, and a citizen of the United States of America understand today by the word “liberty.” For each of them
·         it is the right to be subjected only to the laws,
·         and to be neither arrested, detained, put to death or maltreated in any way by the arbitrary will of one or more individuals.
·         It is the right of everyone to express their opinion,
·         choose a profession and practice it,
·         to dispose of property, and even to abuse it;
·         to come and go without permission, and without having to account for their motives or undertakings.
·         It is everyone’s right to associate with other individuals, either to discuss their interests, or to profess the religion which they and their associates prefer,
·         or even simply to occupy their days or hours in a way which is most compatible with their inclinations or whims.
·         Finally it is everyone’s right to exercise some influence on the administration of the government, either by electing all or particular officials, or through representations, petitions, demands to which the authorities are more or less compelled to pay heed.

If that is freedom, which we mainly agree we want, then why do so many people want government that will take, by force, wealth from some and arbitrarily give it to others?

Why are there speech codes to prevent free speech on school and college campuses?

Why are there unelected government officials deciding how a person can use his own property, if a puddle gets called a wetland, or a particular creature is found upon the property?

Why are people compelled to buy insurance, at ever higher rates, regardless of their health or willingness to pay for care out-of-pocket?

Why are business owners being compelled to violate their own religious practices, or else be forced out of business?

Why did my school district get threatened with a lawsuit (by someone not even in the district) for having an opening prayer at its board meetings?

Why are people blacklisted, or have their property defaced, for supporting one particular candidate or another, or for belonging to a particular party, or holding the beliefs that our country was founded upon?

Why are people being forced to share bathroom or locker room spaces with people of the opposite sex?

Why are certain officials allowed to break the law with impunity while the rest of us are prosecuted?

Why is there so much indoctrination and enforcement in education, at such high cost for such poor results?

Why are states being forced by a bare majority of unelected judges to redefine marriage away from what it has been for all the millennia of recorded history?

Why is government outlawing entry-level jobs that bring in less than $15 in value per hour?

The questions could go on. On one side of the spectrum—the liberal elite, the progressives, the socialists, or whatever you want to call them—people are in favor of coercion, manipulation, and tyranny. In Spherical Model language, they are all for southern hemisphere tyranny and against freedom—although they are often just fine with libertine licentiousness.

On the other side of the spectrum—the Constitutional conservatives—people are in favor of northern hemisphere freedom, prosperity, and civilization, based on principles.

There is no point to compromise. Example: Say you have a very bad house guest who is found with the good silverware, falling out of his sleeve as he says goodbye at the door. Instead of returning it, he unabashedly keeps all the pieces still awkwardly up his sleeve and says, “I’ll just take this fork, and you can keep that knife.” When someone is taking our freedom, that is what compromise looks like. It’s not acceptable.

The appropriate response would be to detain the guest, recover all of your silverware, warn all of your friends—and possibly call the police to prevent the guy from stealing from others. In order to do that, you have to have a concept of what is right, what you own, and what civilized behavior requires of guests. For most people, that’s pretty clear.

So, with recovering our freedom, maybe we could use some righteous indignation. Maybe we need to speak up and remind everyone what freedoms God endowed us with--and stop giving in to that thief pretending to be your guest, who requires even more of you after you notice the thieving.

Monday, October 3, 2016

The Separation of School from State

There’s more going on this fall than the presidential election. Some of it is closer to home, and with more immediate effect on our families. Here in Texas it’s time to gear up for the upcoming bi-annual legislative session, from mid-January to early June. Some bills start getting preliminary bill numbers in a month or so. If we can get the attention of our legislators early, we may be able to persuade them to work on the legislation we’re interested in.

I’m working on a list. One of the main big issues is education. This week I happened upon a couple of inputs to my thinking. One is a video called “It’s Time for School Choice in Texas.” It’s only about 8 minutes, so worth watching in full. But here are some of the details.

Texas spends an average of $12,761 per student, for 4.8 million students. Education makes up 52.7% of the state’s general budget. After you watch the video, we’ll talk about it some more.




Data may not mean much without some context. So I did some research. The Cato Institute has come up with a different way of looking at the numbers. Instead of an annual cost per student, they look at the total cost of educating a student K-12, and use inflation-adjusted dollars.

Image from Cato Institute with more detail here


This chart takes us only through 2012. Nationally, and also in Texas, there has been some slowdown, and even decrease, in the annual cost per student during 2010-2015. Nevertheless, total cost per student over time has grown exponentially, while results have remained flat.

In economic terms, when the cost for a service has grown exponentially and offers no additional value, we don't purchase that service. Because we have a choice in how to spend our money.

But in government-run education, we do not have a choice. So we are forced to make the purchase regardless of the bad service.

The video talks about several ways of moving toward school choice, summarized as,

Let the money follow the students. And let students and families decide how best to educate their kids.
Whatever we do, choice needs to lead away from publicly funded education. Because wherever government goes beyond its proper role, there will be unintended negative consequences, usually exactly the opposite of the stated goal.

So, if government says the goal is to educate the populace, and particularly to offer education as a way out of permanent poverty, you can expect that government education will be less effective at educating the populace than the other options, and will particularly fail those in poverty.

That means—if you care about the education of your children and the rest of the children in society, you should be against government education.

That is a radical idea today. But a century ago it was still a mainstream thought. Go back 150 years or so, and the idea of government taking over education was crazy radical.

If we need an educated populace—people who are as well-educated as the founding fathers—we need people who avoid the institutionalized indoctrination factories that have been foisted upon us. Especially in this day when so many other educational avenues are available.

Another resource I came across this week was a free ebook by Tom Woods, Education without the State.  He’s a Libertarian, so there are areas where I will disagree with him, but education is not one of them. The first few chapters of the book (the part I’ve read so far) are transcriptions of interviews he has done with people working on educational choice.

Woods begins by pointing out that education is one of the stiffest stumbling blocks against Libertarianism. As Woods says in his introduction, “Public schooling is as close to the official religion of the United States as any institution is ever likely to be. And if you are reading this eBook, you are likely a heretic.”

So, yes, I recognize that I am a heretic. Since I homeschooled my kids for a decade, I already knew that.

About funding, Woods and Sheldon Richman, author of Separating School and State, discuss the usual arguments about budgets:

WOODS: Just about everyone agrees that there are problems with the government-run schools, and the kids aren’t learning what they should be learning, but then come the excuses: this is because the schools have been deprived of funds, and we don’t have the right priorities, and we favor basketball players over scholars. If only we could change this, we could get our act together. Why would you think the solution would instead involve getting rid of the whole system, root and branch?
RICHMAN: Well, the idea that they haven’t spent enough money is laughable. They’ve been spending amazing amounts of money year after year for twenty or so years, in increasing amounts. They haven’t shown any results. There’s no improvement.
The other thing is that the worst districts in the country have the highest per-capita spending. In Detroit, or Chicago, inner-city schools, Washington, D.C., they are spending $10,000 or more per student, and they have worse results even than other public school districts, government school districts, that spend less per capita. There is no correlation between the amount of money spent and the performance of the children. So that is not the problem.[i]
One of the larger arguments is about educating the poor. Without government schools, wouldn’t poor kids be stuck in poverty? Richman addresses that:

Government produces many obstacles to individual self-advancement economically. And one of the biggest obstacles is its schools. If you look at the inner-city schools, they are just sabotaging generation after generation. If you set out to ruin generations of kids, you could not design a better system than the one we have. So that’s one reason alone that parents don’t seem to have enough money to educate their kids.[ii]
The next chapter hits that idea even harder. Woods interviews Pauline Dixon, who has been doing research into private schools for the poor. She has been to very poor, slum areas, in Africa, China, and India, places identified by UNESCO or the World Bank as very poor. And they found low-cost private schools in all of these areas. Here’s part of their discussion:

WOODS: I think what surprised me the most about your talk was the very existence of the low-cost private schools that you were finding in these various places. That runs contrary to the expectations of many people. It runs contrary to the expectations of certain economic models that hold education to be a public good, which will therefore be underfunded on the market. So what’s going on here? Tell us something about the types of schools that you encountered and how it’s possible that they were, from the West’s point of view, anyway, more or less under the radar all this time.
DIXON: Exactly right. The main reason parents are voting with their feet away from the state sector is that the state sector is failing them. These parents don’t read World Bank reports. They don’t wait around for governments to actually do something for them, because their governments aren’t going to do something for them. So these parents have to do something for themselves. And what happened in India, for example, was that entrepreneurs within certain areas were finding that government schools were teaching only in Hindi or the local language, and that’s not what parents wanted. Parents wanted schools that were what’s called English Medium. That means that their children were going to read and write in English. So local entrepreneurs, because these schools grow organically within the communities themselves, started off what we call low-cost private schools in order to satisfy parental demand.
What happened, for example in India, is that parents started moving away from the government schools. What you tend to think is that a government school would be provided free, but there are always these hidden costs. Parents still have to buy a uniform. They have to buy books. There’s transport to schools and so on. And the local private schools weren’t actually that much more costly for the parent than sending your child to a government school. A low-cost private school costs maybe $4, $5, $6 per month per child, which is about six percent of a worker’s daily wage. So in India, for example, what we found was that these low-cost private schools have sprung up because parents wanted English Medium. That’s the main thing. But also because the government schools were failing.[iii]
In the next chapter Woods interviews James Tooley, author of The Beautiful Tree, about these unlikely private schools. Tooley says,

I’ve been recently in Liberia, south Sudan, and Sierra Leone, and the same phenomenon exists. You talk to people in government or NGOs, non-government organizations, or middle-class people, and even they don’t know about it. So it is extraordinary. The poor are doing something for themselves all over the world, and yet somehow people refuse to accept that they are doing it.[iv]
What I would like to assert is that parents have the role of seeing to the care and education of their own children. When they love their children, they sense this responsibility and act on it. I know I did. Whatever the cost in time and effort, within the limits of our financial means, I would do it. I’m middle class and not on the verge of starvation, but I did have to stand up against some pretty strong social forces to do what I knew was better for my children. 

That is what good parents do, regardless of their circumstances.

In the video above, there’s this quote from economist Milton Friedman:

As long as the schools are governmental, as long as they are financed and administered by public entities, they are a source of political power.
Friedman was actually one of the first proponents of the voucher system, an attempt to move choice from government to parents. School lobbies fight it tooth vouchers tooth and nail. As a homeschooling parent, while I wasn’t against the voucher movement, I was very wary of anything that might give government control over what I was doing in my private school with my kids. Woods and Richman have a discussion about that, worth reading.[v] I think Richman may be right that it isn’t even a step in the right direction.

But the concept of school choice is the right direction, however we accomplish it. The above video suggests a list, some of which I could argue for:

·         Education Savings Accounts
·         Scholarship Tax Credits
·         Expand Charter Schools
·         Better Parent Trigger Laws
·         Home-Rule School Districts
·         School Finance Reform
I’m particularly interested in Education Savings Accounts, and I’ll be bringing this idea to legislators this session. I’m uncertain of the details on several of the other suggestions. For now, I’m favoring ESAs, because there’s so much in control of the parents, and such a wide array of options. But ESAs have to be implemented without government interference into content/indoctrination.

If we succeed in returning people to recognizing education as a family responsibility, instead of a government “service,” we can also return to the idea of using charitable donations from businesses and individuals to offer support to the poor, so that every student willing to learn gets to learn.




[i] Tom Woods, Education without the State,  p. 4.
[ii] Ibid. p. 5.
[iii] Ibid. p. 12-13.
[iv] Ibid, p. 19.
[v] Ibid, p. 7.